01
Best overall pick
Michael's Pizzeria
Along National Road In Jacksontown • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Thin, well-topped pies and friendly service make Michael's the go-to pizza stop in Jacksontown.
This cozy sit-down spot feels like the kind of pizzeria every small town hopes to have, with crisp-edged pies and a familiar, friendly crew. Locals lean toward classic combos piled with pepperoni and sausage, plus a side of wings or a salad when they want to make it a fuller meal. It is an easy choice when you want solid pizza without leaving Jacksontown.
02
Lakefront favorite
Pizza Cottage Buckeye Lake
Buckeye Lake Shoreline • Lakefront Pizza And Patio Spot • Best For Groups And Patios
Big pies, generous toppings, and a casual lakeside vibe make Pizza Cottage a natural stop before or after time on the water.
Just a quick drive from Jacksontown, this outpost overlooks the Buckeye Lake scene and leans into the relaxed, summer-night energy. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and shareable appetizers and cold drinks make it easy to linger with a group. Grab a table on the patio when the weather cooperates and stretch dinner into an evening by the water.
03
Road-trip stop
Donatos Pizza Hebron
Hebron Strip Near I-70 • Fast-Casual Ohio Pizza Chain • Family-Friendly Choice
Donatos in Hebron turns out its signature edge-to-edge topping pies, handy for quick dinners on the way to or from the highway.
For families and travelers, this Donatos is a practical option with consistent, thin-crust pizzas and plenty of topping combinations. The dining room is casual and kid-friendly, and carryout is streamlined if you are hauling boxes back to a rental or campsite near the lake. It is less about ambience and more about getting hot, familiar pizza fast.
04
Downtown classic
Plaza Pizza
Downtown Newark Near The Square • Old-School Local Pizza Shop • Best For Classic Pies
Plaza Pizza is a Newark staple, known for straightforward, satisfying pies that hit the spot after a day in town.
If you do not mind the short drive into Newark, Plaza Pizza offers the kind of no-frills, long-running shop that many locals grew up with. The emphasis is on classic toppings, steady quality, and a crust that holds up whether you eat in or carry out. It is a good call when you want a traditional pizza night after errands or events downtown.
05
Game-day pick
Massey's Pizza
Heath Shopping Corridor • Sports-Bar Style Pizza Joint • Game-Day Gathering Spot
Massey's in Heath pairs hefty, edge-to-edge pizzas with a lively, TV-filled setting that suits sports fans and bigger groups.
This location draws people from Jacksontown and Newark when they want pizza plus a place to watch the game. The pies are loaded with toppings, and there are plenty of sides and beverages to stretch a meal through all four quarters or extra innings. It works well for birthday gatherings, team outings, or any night when the group wants a louder, high-energy spot.