01
Best overall pick
Bentino's Pizza
Downtown Jamestown • Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Jamestown’s go-to spot for a dependable pie, generous toppings, and friendly small-town service.
Bentino's is the kind of place where locals know the staff and the staff knows their regular orders, which tells you a lot about its place in the community. The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, making it a solid option if you like your pizza loaded. It’s a convenient choice for carryout on busy weeknights, but there’s enough space to sit and eat if you’re not in a rush.
02
Best quirky classic
Ha Ha Pizza
Yellow Springs Village Center • Bohemian College-Town Slice Shop • Best For Creative Toppings
A Yellow Springs institution known for offbeat topping combos, a laid-back vibe, and plenty of veggie-friendly options.
Ha Ha Pizza has been a staple for students, hikers, and day-trippers for decades, and it leans into the artsy character of Yellow Springs. You’ll find inventive topping combinations, a strong showing of vegetarian choices, and a crust that strikes a balance between chewy and crisp. It’s an easy stop to pair with browsing the village shops or a visit to nearby trails and parks.
03
Best old-school option
Xenia Pizza & Spaghetti House
Downtown Xenia • Old-School Pizza And Pasta Joint • Best For Hearty Comfort Food
A throwback spot where you can linger over classic pies, red-sauce pasta, and a relaxed sit-down meal.
Xenia Pizza & Spaghetti House feels like the kind of place families have been visiting for generations, with big red-sauce plates and straightforward, satisfying pizza. The menu runs beyond pies, so it works well when someone in the group wants pasta or a sub instead. Plan to dine in when you’re not in a hurry and want a comfortable, no-frills evening out after the short drive from Jamestown.
04
Best fast-casual stop
Rapid Fired Pizza
North Xenia Retail Corridor • Build-Your-Own Fast-Casual Spot • Best Quick Option After A Game
Customize your own thin-crust pie and have it out of the oven in minutes, ideal for busy nights and hungry kids.
Rapid Fired Pizza lets everyone build exactly the pizza they want, from sauce to finish, which can save a lot of negotiation with a crowd. The high-heat ovens turn out personal-sized pies quickly, making it an easy stop after sports, errands, or a movie in Xenia. It’s more about speed and customization than lingering, so think of it as a practical, good-tasting option when time is tight.
05
Best big-group choice
Marion's Piazza
Beavercreek Shopping District • Classic Dayton-Style Pizza Parlor • Best For Big Gatherings
A Dayton-area landmark for ultra-thin crust pizza, cut in squares and served in a spacious, family-friendly dining room.
If you’re willing to drive a bit farther, Marion's in Beavercreek is a go-to for parties, team celebrations, and extended family dinners. The signature ultra-thin crust and square-cut slices make it easy to share several different topping combos across the table. With plenty of seating and a distinct retro feel, it’s the spot to pick when you want pizza to be the centerpiece of a get-together, not just a quick meal.