01
Best overall pick
Heavenly Pizza
Findlay – East Side • Counter-Service Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Classic Carryout
A long-running Findlay favorite with hearty, topping-heavy pies that travel well back to Jenera.
Heavenly Pizza is the kind of reliable, old-school spot locals lean on for weeknight dinners and team parties. The crust is sturdy enough for extra cheese and loaded toppings, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to meat-heavy specialty pizzas. Call ahead from Jenera and your order is usually ready by the time you reach the east side of Findlay.
02
Best specialty pie stop
Dougie's Pizza Co.
Findlay – South End • Modern Takeout Pizzeria With Build-Your-Own Options • Best For Creative Specialty Pies
A fresher, slightly more modern take on Ohio pizza with lots of toppings and crust options.
Dougie's Pizza Co. is a solid choice when you want something beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine. Their menu leans into loaded specialty pies and customizable builds, so everyone in the car from Jenera can get what they want. It is a convenient stop if you are already running errands on Findlay's south side and need pizza that feels a bit more upgraded than basic chain fare.
03
Best sit-down choice
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Findlay – Tiffin Avenue Corridor • Full-Service Pizza And Grill Restaurant • Best For Family Dinners
A roomy, family-friendly grill where pizza anchors a big menu of pub favorites.
If you want to make pizza the centerpiece of a night out rather than a quick pickup, Beer Barrel on Tiffin Avenue is the easy crowd-pleaser. The thick, chewy crust and generous cheese make their pizzas ideal for sharing, and the wider menu keeps non-pizza people happy. It is an especially good option for Jenera families meeting friends from around Hancock County in a central, easy-to-find spot.
04
Best small-town classic
Jac & Do's Pizza
Arlington Village Center • Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Best Small-Town Stop
A cozy Arlington staple with the kind of straightforward, comforting pies small towns do best.
Just a short drive southwest of Jenera, Jac & Do's in Arlington feels like the textbook local pizza joint. Expect a friendly, low-key dining room, straightforward toppings, and crust that hits the sweet spot between crisp and soft. It is a natural choice when you want to stay close to Jenera but still get that classic dine-in parlor experience.
05
Best for a post-game bite
East of Chicago Pizza
Bluffton – Main Street Area • Casual Chain Pizzeria With Local Following • Best For Dine-In And Drinks
A familiar regional name that serves up thick, saucy pies ideal after a Bluffton game or event.
Bluffton's East of Chicago outpost draws a steady mix of students, families, and locals who like the hearty, pan-style crust and buffet-style options at peak times. For Jenera residents, it pairs easily with a trip to Bluffton's small shops or a school event, giving you a relaxed spot to linger over pizza afterward. It is not fancy, but it is reliably satisfying and welcoming to groups.