01
Best small-town classic
Eagles Pizza
Historic Downtown New Albany • Old-School Family Pizzeria • Local Institution
A New Albany landmark turning out comforting, crowd-pleasing pies in a hometown setting.
Eagles Pizza has been the go-to slice for New Albany families for decades, and it is an easy drive straight south from Jersey. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and doughy, with toppings piled generously but not sloppily. Go for a classic pepperoni or their well-loved specialty combos, and expect to run into neighbors on busy game nights.
02
Most creative pies
Mellow Mushroom
New Albany Off Oh-161 • Craft Pizza And Beer Spot • Best For Lingering With Friends
Colorful, lively, and known for inventive stone-baked pies with a big craft beer list.
If you want something beyond the usual pepperoni, Mellow Mushroom in New Albany is where the toppings get playful. Expect chewy, flavorful crusts and options like gourmet white pies, loaded veggie creations, and hearty meat combos. The dining room is bright and relaxed, making it a popular choice for post-practice team dinners and casual nights out.
03
Neighborhood favorite
Cardinal Pizza Shop
Westerville Neighborhood Strip • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Best Takeout Option
A no-frills, high-reliability shop turning out crisp-edged pies that travel well.
Cardinal Pizza Shop in Westerville is a solid bet when you want hot, well-made pizza without the fuss. The crust bakes up nicely crisp on the bottom, with just enough chew to stand up to heavier toppings. It is especially popular for carryout and delivery, making it a convenient option for Jersey households looking to feed a crowd at home.
04
Best for game-day
Grapevine Pizza
Gahanna • Sports-Bar Style Pizza Joint • Best For Watching The Game
A lively spot pairing hefty pizzas with plenty of TVs and cold drinks.
Grapevine Pizza in Gahanna leans into the game-day atmosphere, with big screens, generous toppings, and shareable pies. Their crust is sturdy and sauce-forward, ideal if you like a pizza that feels substantial. It is a good choice when you want to settle in for a Buckeyes game, grab wings on the side, and still have leftovers to take back to Jersey.
05
Family-night standby
Creno's Pizza
Pataskala • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Families
A dependable Pataskala staple known for square-cut pies and generous toppings.
Creno's Pizza in Pataskala brings that familiar, no-nonsense Ohio pizzeria feel, complete with edge-to-edge toppings and a sauce that leans slightly sweet. Many families from the Jersey area make the short drive here for easy weeknight dinners and relaxed weekends. Order a large square-cut pie, add some garlic bread, and you are set for a low-key night in.