01
Closest full-service pick
Pasquale's Pizza & Subs
Woodsfield • Small-Town Pizza Shop With Subs And Appetizers • Local Favorite
The go-to hometown spot in Woodsfield for a straightforward, satisfying pizza night.
Pasquale's is the kind of place where Monroe County families have been ordering the same pies for years. Expect a classic, slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and generous toppings rather than trendy experiments. It’s an easy choice when you want reliable takeout or a casual bite after errands in Woodsfield.
02
Best for delivery convenience
Domino's Pizza
Woodsfield • National Delivery Chain • Best For Fast Delivery
A practical option when you want consistent, customizable pizza delivered out toward the back roads.
Woodsfield’s Domino’s is a workhorse for busy weeknights, ball games, and last-minute gatherings. Online ordering and predictable delivery make it especially handy for folks living just outside town. Stick with their specialty pizzas or build your own with extra toppings if you like a heavier, cheese-forward pie.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Barnesville • Family-Friendly Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
A familiar spot where families from around Jerusalem meet up for pan pizzas, breadsticks, and a relaxed meal.
The Barnesville Pizza Hut gives you that old-school dine-in experience that’s getting harder to find. Their pan and hand-tossed pizzas come with the classic buttery crust and plenty of sauce, and kids tend to love the breadsticks and simple toppings. It’s a nice choice when you’d rather sit down in a booth than rush back home with a box.
04
Worth-the-drive regional classic
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
St. Clairsville • Regional Ohio Valley Pizzeria • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
A long-time Ohio Valley name turning out hefty, topping-packed pizzas that feel like a small road trip reward.
DeFelice Bros. in St. Clairsville is a favorite when locals want something a little different from the big national chains. Their pizzas lean hearty, with a thicker crust, lots of cheese, and specialty combinations that are piled high. Plan it as a dinner stop alongside a run to the big-box stores and you’ll see why people speak highly of their pies.
05
Best for variety and big orders
Vocelli Pizza
St. Clairsville • Casual Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Group Orders
A flexible option with plenty of topping combos, sides, and sizes that works well for teams and family get-togethers.
Vocelli in St. Clairsville is popular with groups thanks to its broad menu of pizzas, wings, and breadsticks. The crust runs on the thinner, crisper side compared with some nearby spots, and their specialty pies give you more variety than just pepperoni and cheese. It’s a smart call when you’re feeding a crowd after a game or shopping run.