01
Worth the drive
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Destination Pie
Thoughtful toppings and a focus on local ingredients make this one of the most distinctive pizzas within range of Jewett.
If you do not mind a bit of a drive, Park Street Pizza rewards you with carefully sourced toppings, crisp-edged crusts, and a menu that changes with the seasons. It is the kind of place where you can taste the difference in the sauce and cheese, and where ordering a couple of specialty pies to share is half the fun. Pair your pizza with a craft soda or locally minded side and linger a while in the relaxed dining room.
02
Classic Ohio Valley style
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Steubenville Historic District • Square-Cut Ohio Valley Shop • Local Favorite
A quick drive from Jewett gets you to the original home of Ohio Valley-style pizza, served as hot crust with cool cheese.
DiCarlo's is a regional institution, known for its square slices with sauce and crust baked first, then finished with a layer of cool shredded cheese. It is a simple, no-frills setup where people pop in for a box or two to take home, and there is nearly always someone grabbing a tray for a ballgame or family get-together. If you have never tried this style before, start with a basic pepperoni and let the contrast of temperatures and textures win you over.
03
Old-school red-sauce joint
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Dennison Rail District • Family Italian Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
A cozy, old-school spot where pizza shares the spotlight with big plates of pasta and family-style service.
Pangrazio's feels like the sort of place families around Dennison have been coming to for generations, and it is an easy choice when you want more than just a quick slice. The pizza leans classic Midwestern, with a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and generous toppings, and the menu stretches out to include spaghetti, salads, and shareable appetizers. It is a relaxed option when you are meeting friends from around the county and want to linger over a full meal.
04
Reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Cadiz Commercial Strip • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Families
A familiar stop close to Jewett where you can count on classic pan pizzas, breadsticks, and plenty of space for a group.
When you are keeping things simple, the Pizza Hut in Cadiz delivers the kind of predictable, crowd-pleasing pies everyone recognizes. It is especially handy for families coming into town for errands or school events, with flexible seating and a menu that keeps kids and picky eaters happy. Order a couple of pan pizzas, add some wings and breadsticks, and you are set for an easy dinner back home in Jewett.
05
Late-night standby
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia Commercial Corridor • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Late-Night And Game Days
A go-to for fast, customizable pizzas when you are passing through New Philadelphia or planning a big game-night order.
Domino's in New Philadelphia is a practical choice when you need pizza on a schedule, from weeknight dinners to road-trip stops on the way back toward Jewett. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time pickup, and the range of crusts, sauces, and toppings means everyone can build their own favorite. It is less about ambiance and more about getting hot, predictable pizza into the car and back home without fuss.