01
Best overall pick
The Pizzeria
Ottawa • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
A short drive east of Kalida gets you to hearty, edge-to-edge pies that many Putnam County locals call their must-try pizza.
The Pizzeria leans into the kind of generous toppings and well-browned cheese that define northwest Ohio comfort food. Expect a crisp-but-not-thin crust, plenty of classic choices, and friendly counter service that remembers regulars. It’s an easy choice when you want a dependable pie that still feels proudly local.
02
Best for thick-crust slices
Padrone's Pizza
Glandorf • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Game-Night Takeout
Square-cut, sauce-forward pizzas and solid value make this a handy option when you’re feeding a crew around Kalida.
Padrone's does the classic Ohio-style square cut with a slightly thicker, chewy crust that holds up well under toppings. It’s the sort of place you call when there’s a game on, kids to feed, and no time to fuss. Keep an eye on their specials board, which often turns a couple of large pies into an easy, budget-friendly spread.
03
Best for big groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Lima • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Teams
Big, shareable pizzas, lots of TVs, and a broad menu make this Lima standby a go-to after tournaments or shopping runs.
Beer Barrel is built for gatherings, with roomy booths, plenty of screens, and pizzas sized for sharing. The crust runs on the thicker side, with a focus on hearty toppings and crowd-pleasing combinations. It’s a natural stop when you’ve got a car full of hungry people coming back toward Kalida from Lima.
04
Classic Lima slice
Fat Jack's Pizza
North Lima • Old-School Takeout Slice Shop • Best For Late-Night Cravings
A Lima institution known for generous cheese, crispy edges, and the kind of carryout boxes that have perfumed many drives back to Kalida.
Fat Jack's feels like the archetypal small-city pizza joint: straightforward, a little nostalgic, and focused on getting hot pies out the door fast. The crust bakes up with caramelized cheese at the edges, and the toppings lean hearty rather than dainty. It’s ideal when you don’t need frills, just a solid pizza waiting to be opened on the kitchen table.
05
Familiar chain comfort
Pizza Hut – Ottawa
Ottawa Strip • Family-Friendly National Chain • Most Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
A close-by option when you want the comfort of a familiar menu, from pan pizzas to breadsticks, with easy ordering and pickup.
Ottawa’s Pizza Hut is the dependable choice for families who know exactly what everyone likes. The pan crust and stuffed-crust options are especially popular with kids, and the menu has enough wings, sides, and desserts to round out a casual night in. For visitors staying nearby, it’s a low-stress way to feed a mixed group without debating styles or toppings for too long.