Kelleys Island may be small, but it sits in the middle of a Lake Erie shoreline that takes its pizza seriously. From a laid-back island bar serving crowd-pleasing pies to beloved taverns and sports cafés just a ferry ride away, you’re never far from a good slice. Use this guide to plan where to refuel between beach time, boating, and exploring the islands.
Laid-back island hangout known for hearty pizzas, cold beer, and a lively patio steps from the ferry action.
If you want pizza without leaving Kelleys Island, Caddy Shack is the easy choice. The pies are generously topped, great for sharing, and pair well with a game on TV or a round of wings. It’s the kind of place where boaters, campers, and day-trippers all end up sooner or later.
A Port Clinton standby serving crisp, cheesy bar-style pies that locals swear by before and after island trips.
Just across the water in Port Clinton, Bell Mell’s is the kind of neighborhood tavern where the pizza has a loyal following. Expect a crisp crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings done right. It’s an easy stop before catching the ferry or on your way home from the islands.
High-energy spot famed for loaded specialty pizzas and a sports-bar atmosphere near the Marblehead ferries.
Sloopy’s is known around the Lake Erie shore for big, bold pizzas piled high with toppings. The menu leans into creative combinations, so it’s a fun place to branch out beyond pepperoni. With plenty of TVs and a casual vibe, it’s a natural choice for families and groups coming off the water.
Spacious Sandusky pizzeria turning out crowd-pleasing pies, buffets, and game-day vibes that work well for large parties.
Chet & Matt’s is built for families, teams, and anyone with a serious post-beach appetite. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, and the menu includes plenty of kid-friendly options alongside cold beer for adults. It’s a reliable choice when you need lots of pizza without a lot of fuss.
Cozy Sandusky bistro turning out crisp brick-oven pies with thoughtful toppings and solid salads and sides.
For something a touch more relaxed than a sports bar, Brick Oven Bistro delivers nicely charred pizzas with a mix of classic and more upscale toppings. It’s an easy-going place where you can share a couple of pies, split a salad, and linger over a drink. Pair it with a stroll through downtown Sandusky for a low-key night off the island.