01
Best overall pick
Michael Angelo's Pizza
Downtown Kenton • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Beloved by locals, Michael Angelo’s serves hearty, hand-tossed pies that feel tailor-made for small-town pizza night.[2][4][5]
Locally owned and operated since the late 1990s, Michael Angelo’s is the kind of neighborhood pizzeria where staff remember your usual and the crust is always just the right mix of chewy and crisp.[2][4] The menu leans into classic, generously topped pies and crowd-pleasing specials, with portions sized for families and game-day gatherings.[2][4][5] It’s the spot most Kenton residents recommend first when you ask where to get a ‘real’ local pizza.[5]
02
Best pizza-and-subs combo
Jimmy's Pizza and Subs
South Kenton • Casual Pizza-And-Subs Shop • Best For Game Nights
Jimmy’s pairs classic, saucy pies with hefty subs, making it a reliable choice when your crew wants more than just pizza.[5]
Listed among Kenton’s handful of go-to pizza spots, Jimmy’s Pizza and Subs is a laid-back place where you can grab a pie, a hot sub, and enough sides to cover a whole TV marathon.[5] The pizzas lean comforting and familiar, with plenty of cheese and a saucier profile that works well for pepperoni and meat-lovers styles.[5] Add in the subs and appetizers, and it becomes an easy one-stop order for game nights or casual office lunches.
03
Best value pies
Jac and Do's Pizza
North Kenton • No-Frills Local Pizza Joint • Best For Big Groups On A Budget
Jac and Do’s turns out straightforward, satisfying pizzas at prices that make feeding a crowd much less painful.[5]
Jac and Do’s is a staple on Kenton pizza lists, known more for solid value and consistency than for chasing trends.[5] Expect classic toppings, a straightforward crust, and combo deals that make it easy to cover birthday parties, team celebrations, or any night when headcount keeps creeping up.[5] It is the kind of place where ordering a stack of large pies feels like a smart move, not a splurge.
04
Most kid-friendly chain
Pizza Hut
East Columbus Street Corridor • Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Families
Kenton’s Pizza Hut delivers the brand’s familiar pan pizzas and wings, with a family-friendly setup locals know by heart.[1][5]
Set along East Columbus Street, Kenton’s Pizza Hut offers the comfort of a national menu—think pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and wings—backed by flexible carryout and delivery hours that run late into the evening.[1] For many families, it is the default choice when everyone wants something predictable and easy, especially on busy weeknights.[1][5] Deals on bundles and shareable sides make it a practical option when you are feeding kids and teens without overcomplicating the order.[1]
05
Fastest delivery pick
Domino's Pizza
North Main Street • Delivery-Focused Chain Spot • Late-Night Delivery Pick
Domino’s on North Main leans into speed and customization, with online ordering and quick delivery for those last-minute cravings.[3][5]
From its North Main Street location, Domino’s gives Kenton diners the full menu of build-your-own and specialty pizzas, plus wings, pastas, and desserts geared toward delivery and carryout.[3] Online and app ordering make it easy to tweak crusts, sauces, and toppings, so everyone in the house gets their preferred style without a phone negotiation.[3] With evening hours and a strong delivery focus, it is particularly handy for late study sessions, overtime shifts, or nights when cooking is off the table.[3][5]