01
Best overall pick
Jimmy's Italian Kitchen
Dorothy Lane Corridor • Cozy Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best Sit-Down Experience
A warm, family-run Italian spot where the pizza is as much a draw as the pasta and red-sauce classics.
Jimmy's feels like the kind of place regulars return to every week, with red-check table vibes and servers who remember your usual order. The pizza leans classic and comforting, with a well-seasoned sauce and a generous layer of cheese that crisps nicely at the edges. It is the top choice when you want a lingering, sit-down meal rather than a quick grab-and-go slice.
02
Best for classic slices
Troni Brothers Pizza
East Kettering • No-Frills New York–Style Shop • Go-To For Thin, Foldable Pies
A straightforward slice joint known for big, foldable pies and a just-greasy-enough New York attitude.
Troni Brothers keeps the focus firmly on the pizza: crisp-yet-chewy crust, a bright tomato sauce, and toppings that stay put when you fold a slice. The space is simple and a bit tight, but that only adds to its grab-a-box-and-go energy. It is an easy recommendation when you want something that tastes like a city slice without leaving Kettering.
03
Classic carryout favorite
Palermo's
Near The Oakwood Border • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Takeout Nights
A longtime neighborhood standby turning out hearty, cheese-forward pies that travel well.
Palermo's has the feel of a place that has been fueling local game nights and movie marathons for years. The crust runs on the thicker, more substantial side, built to handle extra cheese and a heavy hand with toppings. Call ahead, grab your boxes, and you have an easy, reliable option for feeding a crowd without much fuss.
04
Best for big groups
Gionino's Pizzeria
Far Hills Corridor • Regional Chain With Ohio-Style Pies • Ideal For Sharing And Parties
A regional favorite known for thickly topped pies and big orders that show up hot and on time.
Gionino's is built for hungry groups, with sturdy crusts and edge-to-edge cheese that make every square cut count. The menu runs wide, so you can add wings or fried chicken when you are feeding a mixed crowd. It is especially handy when you need consistent, family-pleasing pizza for parties, office lunches, or game-day spreads.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Joe's Pizzeria
South Dayton, Short Drive From Kettering • Classic Dayton-Style Tavern Pizza • Best Nearby Destination Pie
A beloved Dayton institution serving crisp, square-cut tavern pies that many locals rank among the area's best.
Joe's sits just outside Kettering but earns its spot on any local pizza short list. The pies are classic Dayton-style: thin, crunchy crust, finely chopped toppings, and those nostalgic square slices that disappear faster than you expect. If you are willing to take a short drive, this is the spot that often turns casual visitors into loyal regulars.