Kidron may be a quiet crossroads village, but its pizza options punch above their weight thanks to a deep local love of hearty, no-nonsense pies. Within a short drive you can find everything from old-school pan pizza to crisp, creative slices near the college crowd in Wooster. These five spots make an easy starting list when you’re craving a low-key night in or a post-Lehman’s Hardware meal.
Straightforward, well-topped pies and subs right in the middle of Kidron.
Kidron Pizza Company is the kind of no-frills counter spot locals rely on for busy weeknights and game days. Crusts lean on the classic side, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel more generous than fussy. Call in an order, swing through after a Lehman’s run, and you’ll see half the community doing the same thing.
Crusty, cheese-heavy pies paired with their well-known fried chicken and JoJo potatoes.
Gionino's in the Kidron area is a go-to when you need to feed a lot of people without overthinking it. Thick, satisfying pizzas and crispy chicken buckets make it easy to cover both the pizza fans and the fried-chicken loyalists in one call. It’s a smart move for Sunday gatherings, birthday parties, or anytime the whole extended family shows up.
Build-your-own pies, thick pan options, and a relaxed buffet setup a short hop from Kidron.
Dalton’s East of Chicago is where a lot of local families end up when nobody wants to cook and everyone wants something different. You can go deep-dish, thin, or somewhere in between, and the buffet and salad bar keep kids and adults equally busy. It’s an easy spot for team outings and youth group meetups after a game in town.
Hefty, topping-loaded pies in a cozy dining room that many consider the region’s benchmark pizza.
Coccia House in Wooster is the place people from all over Wayne County talk about when the subject of pizza comes up. The pies are thick with cheese and toppings, with a slightly rustic, made-by-hand feel that has built a loyal following over decades. Plan on a relaxed sit-down meal and a bit of a wait on busy nights, but the experience is half the reason to make the drive from Kidron.
Big, foldable slices and playful topping combos popular with the college and late-shift crowd.
Totally Baked Pizza leans into bolder flavors, with specialty pies and slices that go beyond the typical pepperoni-and-cheese routine. It’s a favorite for students and night owls around Wooster who want something hot and substantial when most of the countryside has gone quiet. If you’re staying nearby or passing through late, this is the spot that’s still likely to be slinging slices.