01
Best in-town slice
Kilbourne Market
Kilbourne • Small-Town Market & Pizzeria • Closest Option To Kilbourne
A true small-town hub where you can grab a hot, made-to-order pizza without leaving Kilbourne.
Part carry-out restaurant, part neighborhood gathering place, Kilbourne Market is the obvious go-to when you want pizza without a drive. The menu leans classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and loaded deluxe pies—but the crust is crisp and the toppings are generous. It’s the spot locals rely on for easy weeknight dinners and casual weekend pick-ups.
02
Best for a night out
Amato's Woodfired Pizza
Downtown Delaware • Wood-Fired Italian Spot • Best For A Sit-Down Night Out
Rustic wood-fired pies in a lively downtown setting, ideal when you want more than just takeout.
Amato’s is where many Delaware County residents head when they’re in the mood for a proper pizza dinner. The wood-fired oven turns out charred, chewy crusts with toppings that go well beyond the basics, and there’s a full bar plus plenty of indoor seating. It’s an easy choice for date night, visiting family, or a pre-event meal near the heart of downtown Delaware.
03
Best for creative toppings
Luna Pizza Kitchen
Delaware • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A relaxed Delaware shop known for well-balanced pies and a lineup of specialty combinations.
Luna Pizza Kitchen has the feel of a neighborhood standby, the kind of place where regulars have a go-to order and staff know it by heart. Classic cheese and pepperoni are solid, but the draw is the specialty pizzas with more adventurous toppings and sauces. It’s a smart pick when you want something a bit different without straying too far from Kilbourne.
04
Best for quick carryout
Romeo's Pizza
Delaware • Modern Takeout And Delivery Chain • Best For Busy Weeknights
Reliable, sauce-forward pies with easy online ordering and fast pickup or delivery from Delaware.
Romeo’s in Delaware is all about convenience without completely sacrificing character. The crust has some heft, the sauce tends to be a bit sweeter, and there are plenty of topping combinations tailored to families and groups. It’s the place to call when you need several pizzas on short notice for a game night, birthday, or last-minute get-together near Kilbourne.
05
Best worth-the-drive option
Good Fella'z Pizzeria
Sunbury • Family-Run Neighborhood Shop • Best For Big Group Orders
Hearty, crowd-pleasing pizzas from a Sunbury favorite that easily justify the short drive from Kilbourne.
Good Fella’z Pizzeria in Sunbury has a loyal following thanks to its generous portions and straightforward, satisfying pies. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, making it ideal for meat-lovers, supreme, and loaded specialty orders. If you’re hosting a group or don’t mind a brief drive for a reliably solid pie, this is a strong addition to the rotation.