01
Best overall pick
East of Chicago Pizza
Millersburg – Downtown • Family-Friendly Pizza Buffet • Best For Families
A hometown staple with thick-crust pies, a popular buffet, and plenty of room for groups.
East of Chicago in Millersburg is the kind of place locals rely on for ball-team outings and easy family dinners. The crust is on the thicker, softer side, with lots of topping options and a steady buffet that keeps everyone fed without much fuss. It is a straightforward, good-value stop when you want pizza, salad, and breadsticks under one roof.
02
Top delivery choice
Pizza Hut
Millersburg – South Washington Street • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Delivery
Familiar pan and stuffed-crust pizzas with reliable delivery back to Killbuck and the back roads around it.
The Millersburg Pizza Hut is the go-to option when you want classic chain pizza without leaving the house. Pan and stuffed-crust pies travel well, and the wings, pasta, and desserts make it easy to cover everyone’s preferences in one order. It is especially handy for Killbuck residents on weeknights when a drive into town is the last thing you want to do.
03
Cozy neighborhood choice
Fox's Pizza Den
Millersburg – West Jackson Street • Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Local Favorite
Laid-back spot known for hearty pies, stromboli-style wedgies, and friendly small-town service.
Fox’s Pizza Den in Millersburg leans into generous portions and comfort-food style pizza. Between the thick, cheesy pies and the loaded wedgies, it is a satisfying option when you are really hungry or feeding a crowd. The low-key, small-town feel makes it a nice change of pace from the bigger chains, while still being an easy drive from Killbuck.
04
Destination pizza night
Table Rock Brick Oven Pizza
Berlin – Just Off Main Street • Brick-Oven Pizzeria • Best Brick-Oven Option
Crisp, brick-oven pizzas with creative toppings in the heart of Amish Country’s busiest village.
Table Rock Brick Oven Pizza in Berlin is worth the extra few miles when you want something beyond the usual chain flavors. The crust comes out thin and crisp from the brick oven, with topping combinations that feel a bit more modern than most nearby spots. Pair it with a stroll through Berlin’s shops and you have an easy pizza-and-Amish-Country evening from Killbuck.
05
Small-town slice stop
Charm Pizza Co.
Charm – Village Center • Small-Town Slice Shop • Best Small-Town Detour
Uncomplicated, well-made pizzas in a laid-back village setting surrounded by farms and rolling hills.
Charm Pizza Co. feels like a classic country-town pizza joint, with straightforward pies that hit the spot after a day out on the back roads. The menu keeps to the essentials—solid crust, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings—served without pretense. It makes a nice detour when you are looping through Charm and the southern side of Holmes County from Killbuck.