01
Best overall pick
Two Cities Pizza Company
Downtown Mason • New York & Chicago-Style Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Lovers
A creative, big-city-style pizzeria that feels like a night out, not just a meal.
Two Cities leans into its New York–meets–Chicago theme with both foldable slices and serious deep dish, all done with a level of care that justifies the buzz. The crusts are well developed, toppings are thoughtful rather than piled on, and the space has a warm, lively feel that works for both date night and families. If you only have time for one pizza stop near Kings Mills, this is the one locals will point you toward.
02
Best slice-and-a-beer stop
Mad Monks Pizza
Mason Town Center • Lively New York-Style Slice Shop And Bar • Best For Craft Beer And A Slice
A relaxed hangout with big New York-style pies, inventive toppings, and a strong tap list.
Mad Monks is the spot when you want a proper hand-tossed, New York-style crust and a cold beer after a long day. Pies lean large and shareable, with plenty of specialty combinations alongside the classic cheese and pepperoni locals swear by. The bar, TVs, and upbeat atmosphere make it a natural choice for groups, especially during game days.
03
Family favorite near the parks
LaRosa's Pizzeria Mason
Near Kings Island • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Go-To For Families And Teams
A reliable local-chain classic with plenty of booths, big menus, and kid-friendly pies.
Just a short hop from Kings Island, LaRosa’s is where many families end up after a day at the park or a youth sports game. The pizza is classic Cincinnati style with a slightly sweet sauce, plenty of topping choices, and crust options to keep everyone at the table happy. With a full menu of hoagies, pastas, and wings, it’s also the easiest place on this list for feeding a crowd with different tastes.
04
Closest classic to Kings Mills
Papa Joe's Pizza
Kings Mills Road Corridor • No-Frills Carryout And Delivery Joint • Quick Local Takeout Pick
A straightforward, locally loved takeout shop that focuses on hot, satisfying pies over frills.
Papa Joe’s sits along Kings Mills Road, making it a convenient option for grabbing a pizza on your way to or from the interstate. The menu hits the essentials—solid crust, generous cheese, and familiar toppings—with a few specialty combinations for regulars who like to mix it up. It’s not trying to be fancy; it’s the kind of dependable neighborhood place you keep on speed dial.
05
Best build-your-own option
Blaze Pizza Mason
Deerfield Towne Center Area • Fast-Casual Build-Your-Own Pizza Spot • Best For Customizable Pies
An assemble-your-own, quick-fire pizza stop that suits picky eaters and mixed groups.
At Blaze, you walk the line, pick your crust, sauce, and toppings, and watch your personal pizza hit the super-hot oven for a quick bake. It’s ideal when everyone wants something different, from simple margherita-style pies to fully loaded creations. The casual setting and efficient service make it a smart pre- or post-errand stop for Kings Mills and Mason locals alike.