01
Best overall pick
Gangbusters Pizza & Country Store
South Of Kingsville Center • Country-Store Pizzeria And Carryout • Local Staple For Hearty Pies
A true Kingsville original combining a small‑town country store with generously topped, crowd‑pleasing pizza.
Tucked along Gageville Monroe Road, Gangbusters feels like the kind of place only locals know, but everyone is happy to share. The pizzas are classic and filling, with plenty of cheese and toppings that make a single pie go a long way for families or small groups. It’s an easy go‑to when you want something dependable, satisfying, and unmistakably Kingsville.
02
Classic neighborhood choice
Covered Bridge Pizza
North Kingsville • Casual Dine‑In Pizzeria • Best For Old‑School Ohio Pizza
A longtime local favorite serving classic northeast Ohio pizza in a laid‑back small‑town setting.
Just up the road in North Kingsville, Covered Bridge Pizza has the kind of nostalgic, no‑rush atmosphere that makes it easy to linger over a pie. The crust lands right between thick and thin, with a balanced, not‑too‑sweet sauce that regulars swear by. It’s the spot to choose when you want to sit down, relax, and enjoy a traditional pizza night without any frills.
03
Most distinctive pies
Nights & Weekends Pizzeria
Historic Ashtabula Harbor • Wood‑Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Best For Food‑Focused Nights Out
A stylish harbor‑area spot turning out blistered, wood‑fired Neapolitan pies a short drive from Kingsville.
Set on Bridge Street in the Ashtabula Harbor district, Nights & Weekends feels more like a destination than a quick stop. The pizzas come out of the wood‑fired oven with leopard‑spotted crusts, light centers, and thoughtful toppings that change with the seasons. Pair a pie with a drink and a stroll along the harbor and you’ve got an easy evening out that still feels special.
04
Dependable takeout favorite
Capp's Pizza
Ashtabula • Casual Regional Pizza Chain • Best For Quick Pickup And Delivery
A reliable Ashtabula standby offering generous, shareable pizzas that travel well back to Kingsville.
Capp’s is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for busy weeknights and game days. The crust is sturdy enough for heavier toppings, and the menu runs from straightforward pepperoni to fully loaded specialty pies. If you’re staying nearby or heading back toward Kingsville, it’s an easy choice when you want plenty of pizza without a long wait.
05
Coziest sit‑down option
Little Italy
Near Downtown Ashtabula • Family‑Style Italian Restaurant • Best For Relaxed Family Dinners
A warm, old‑school Italian spot where pizza shares the spotlight with pastas and red‑sauce comfort dishes.
If you’re in the mood for more than just pizza, Little Italy offers a full menu that still treats its pies as a centerpiece. Expect a softer, classic crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that lean traditional rather than trendy. It’s a comfortable choice for mixed groups where some want pizza, others want pasta, and everyone wants a sit‑down meal that feels unhurried.