01
Best overall pick
Farmhouse Pizzeria
Kinsman Village Center • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Small-Town Staple
A friendly Main Street shop turning out hefty, well-topped pies that feel made for Kinsman Friday nights.
Farmhouse Pizzeria is the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and the pizza comes out hot and generously loaded. The crust is sturdy enough for serious toppings but still soft in the middle, making their specialty pies an easy crowd-pleaser. It’s an obvious first stop if you’re staying in or around Kinsman and want classic, no-fuss hometown pizza.
02
Iconic Brier Hill pick
Sunrise Inn
Downtown Warren • Old-School Italian Tavern • Best For Classic Brier Hill Pizza
A Warren institution known for its pan-baked, sauce-forward Brier Hill pies and lively, lived-in dining room.
Sunrise Inn has been slinging pizza long enough to feel woven into Warren’s downtown history, and locals still pack the dining room for their signature Brier Hill style. Expect a thicker crust, a bright tomato sauce, and a generous shake of Romano and peppers rather than a heavy blanket of cheese. It’s a worthwhile drive from Kinsman when you want a sit-down meal and a truly regional take on pizza.
03
Game-day crowd pleaser
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant
North Warren / Elm Road • Family-Friendly Italian Joint • Best For Big Groups
Big, shareable pies with plenty of cheese and toppings, served in a bright, casual room that suits families and teams.
Belleria leans into that Youngstown–Warren style: slightly thicker crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and toppings that don’t skimp. The dining room is relaxed and noisy in a good way, making it easy to roll in with kids, relatives, or a post-game crew. If you’re coming from Kinsman with a group and want reliable, crowd-pleasing pizza plus pasta and wings, this is an easy bet.
04
Sit-down Italian night
Salvatore's Italian Grill & Pizzeria
Howland, Near Eastwood Mall • Casual Upscale Italian Restaurant • Best For Dinner-And-Drinks
Brick-oven style pies share the menu with classic Italian plates, making it ideal when not everyone at the table wants just pizza.
Salvatore’s offers a step up in ambiance without going stuffy, with a bar area, booths, and plenty of space for a relaxed night out. Their pizzas lean on a thinner, crisper crust with well-balanced toppings, sitting comfortably alongside pastas, salads, and house specialties. It’s a good choice when you’ve driven down from Kinsman and want a full Italian dinner where pizza is still front and center.
05
Cross-border takeout pick
Pizza Joe's
Greenville, Pa Just Over The Line • No-Frills Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Quick Takeout
Square-cut, party-style pizzas with a soft crust and classic toppings, built for easy sharing and easy pickup.
Just across the state line, Pizza Joe’s is a familiar name for anyone who’s spent time in small towns around western Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio. The pies come in that nostalgic, square-cut style with a soft interior and plenty of sauce, ideal for feeding a crowd on short notice. If you’re out toward Greenville from Kinsman and need a fast, reliable pizza stop, this is a convenient, budget-friendly option.