01
Best overall pick
Biga Wood Fired Pizzeria
Kirtland – Chillicothe Road • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria • Best For Fresh, Blistered Crusts
A cozy Kirtland spot turning out char-kissed, wood-fired pies with thoughtfully sourced toppings.
Biga is where locals head when they want pizza that feels a step up from the usual takeout box. The open kitchen and wood-burning oven give every pie that smoky, chewy crust that’s hard to replicate at home. Expect a focused menu of well-balanced combinations, plus a comfortable dining room that works for both date night and relaxed dinners with friends.
02
Go-to takeout
Angelo's Pizzeria
Kirtland – Euclid-Chardon Road • Carryout And Delivery Slice Shop • Best For Busy Weeknights
A reliable Kirtland staple for classic, generously topped pies ready for pickup or delivery.
Angelo's leans into everything you want from a neighborhood pizza joint: familiar flavors, friendly service, and a crust that holds up on the ride home. The menu covers the basics along with a few heartier specialty pizzas, plus wings and subs to round out an order. It’s the kind of place people keep on speed dial for quick dinners, game nights, and feeding a crowd without overthinking it.
03
Neighborhood gem
Down The Block
Central Kirtland • Laid-Back Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Best Low-Key Local Hangout
A small, unpretentious stop where the focus is on hot, satisfying pies and friendly faces.
Down The Block feels like the kind of place you discover once and then keep returning to, especially if you live nearby. The pizzas skew classic and comforting, with plenty of cheese, straightforward toppings, and portions that don’t leave anyone hungry. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed, no-frills pie that still tastes like it was made with care.
04
Best for game night
Tommy Boys
Mentor – Tyler Boulevard Corridor • Lively Sports Bar With Hearty Pizzas • Best For Groups And Big Appetites
A Mentor sports bar slinging shareable pizzas alongside cold drinks and plenty of TV screens.
Tommy Boys is where pizza meets pub energy, making it a natural choice when you want more than just a quiet slice. The pies are robust and load up well with toppings, ideal for splitting at the table while a game plays in the background. With a full bar and a crowd-friendly atmosphere, it works especially well for larger groups coming in from Kirtland Hills or after local events.
05
Worth the drive
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza
Fairport Harbor – Lakeshore District • Casual Brick-Oven Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Outing By The Lake
A Fairport Harbor favorite known for fresh-made dough, brick-oven bake, and a laid-back small-town vibe.
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza rewards the short drive from Kirtland Hills with sturdy, flavorful crust and toppings that feel a notch fresher than average. The brick-oven style gives the pizza a satisfying chew and just enough browning on the edges. It pairs nicely with a walk around Fairport Harbor before or after your meal, turning a simple pizza run into a relaxed evening along the lakeshore.