01
Best overall pick
Ronetti's Pizza
Downtown London • Old-School Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A classic downtown London pizza shop with loyal regulars and generously topped pies.
Ronetti's feels like the kind of small-town pizza place every community wishes it had, with friendly staff and a straightforward menu that keeps the focus on the crust and toppings. It is an easy drive from Lafayette, and many locals make it their go-to for Friday night carryout. Expect hearty, square-cut pies, plenty of cheese, and a cozy, no-frills dining room.
02
Classic small-town slice
Cappy's Pizza
East London • Family-Friendly Pizza Joint • Best For Families
Relaxed, family-oriented spot turning out crowd-pleasing pizzas and other comfort-food staples.
Cappy's is the place where teams pile in after games and families linger over big combo pies. The crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy enough for lots of toppings without feeling heavy. With friendly service, plenty of seating, and a menu that usually goes beyond pizza, it is a dependable choice when you are coming in from Lafayette with a crew to feed.
03
Reliable chain choice
Donatos Pizza
London Shopping Corridor • Ohio Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Takeout
A familiar Ohio favorite known for thin crusts and edge-to-edge toppings, ideal for quick pickup or delivery.
Donatos brings a consistent, thin-crust option that many central Ohio residents already know by heart. Its London location is especially convenient if you are coming in from Lafayette to run errands and want an easy pickup on the way home. Crisp crust, lots of topping combinations, and efficient service make it a smart choice when you care more about speed and predictability than lingering over a meal.
04
Game-day favorite
Flyers Pizza & Subs
West Jefferson • Lively Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Groups
A central Ohio mini-chain with hefty pizzas, subs, and plenty of space for hungry groups.
Flyers in West Jefferson is a popular stop for game nights and casual gatherings, thanks to its big pies and shareable sides. The pizza skews classic Ohio style with a slightly thicker crust and generous toppings, and the subs give non-pizza fans something solid to choose from. From Lafayette, it makes a nice meet-in-the-middle spot if you are getting friends together from around the county.
05
Worth-the-drive option
Jan & Tony's Pizza
Plain City • Cozy Hometown Pizzeria • Destination Pie
A long-running Plain City favorite known for square-cut pies and a relaxed, small-town vibe.
Jan & Tony's draws regulars from all over the northwest side of central Ohio, and it is close enough to Lafayette to justify the drive when you want something a little different. The pizza is cut tavern-style, with a sauce-forward profile and a comforting, old-school feel. Settle into a booth, split a couple of large pies, and make an evening out of it before heading back across the countryside.