01
Classic valley square cuts
DiCarlo's Pizza – St. Clairsville
National Road Corridor, St. Clairsville • Old-School Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Classic Local Legend
A must-try for the signature Ohio Valley style: pan-baked crust, sauce, and cheese added hot out of the oven.
If you grew up anywhere in the Ohio Valley, this is probably what you picture when you think of pizza night. The pies come out with a light, crisp base, tangy sauce, and that unmistakable layer of cheese tossed on after baking. It’s an easy drive from Lafferty and a smart first stop if you want the most region-defining slice around.
02
Best for big family orders
DeFelice Bros Pizza – St. Clairsville
Downtown St. Clairsville • Family-Friendly Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Families
A Belmont County standby with hearty pies, lots of topping choices, and shareable sides for a full-family spread.
DeFelice Bros leans into generous portions, thick cheese coverage, and a slightly heartier crust that travels well back to Lafferty. The menu reads like a greatest-hits list: classic pepperoni, loaded deluxe pies, and plenty of wings and sides. It’s an easy choice when you’re feeding a crowd and don’t want to overthink the order.
03
Big-slice crowd-pleaser
Pizza Milano – St. Clairsville
Near Ohio Valley Mall, St. Clairsville • Casual New York–Style Slice Joint • Go-To For Big, Customizable Pies
Known for its large, foldable slices and build-your-own pies, this spot hits the sweet spot between classic and customizable.
Pizza Milano is where you go when everyone wants something a little different on their pizza. The crust runs thinner and more flexible, with plenty of edge for those who love a good handle on their slice. Between the broad topping list and the convenient location by the mall, it’s an easy stop on the way back toward Lafferty.
04
Weeknight delivery hero
Vocelli Pizza – St. Clairsville
East St. Clairsville Residential Strip • Delivery-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Reliable Weeknight Delivery Pick
A solid choice for consistent, made-to-order pies with specialty options and dependable timing.
Vocelli leans into convenience without phoning it in on flavor, offering everything from classic pepperoni to white pizzas and artisan-style combinations. Crust options and sauces give you a little room to experiment if you’re tired of your usual order. For Lafferty residents, it’s a practical go-to when you just want dinner to show up hot and on time.
05
Essential riverside detour
DiCarlo's Pizza – Bellaire
Downtown Bellaire Riverfront • No-Frills Takeout Counter With Local Roots • Essential Stop For Ohio Valley-Style Purists
A classic walk-up DiCarlo’s location that feels like a step back into the Ohio Valley’s pizza past.
This Bellaire outpost keeps things simple: square-cut pans, that familiar DiCarlo’s crust, and cheese scattered on as it comes out of the oven. The shop has a loyal following that happily lines up for a box or two to take home. It’s a bit more of a drive from Lafferty but worth it if you’re already heading toward the river and want a quintessential local slice along the way.