01
Best hometown classic
LaGrange Village Pizza
In The Village Center • Casual Hometown Pizzeria • Go-To Neighborhood Slice
Straightforward, well-topped pies and familiar sides make this the definition of a small-town pizza staple.
LaGrange Village Pizza is the kind of spot where the staff recognizes regulars and a large pepperoni is almost a default order. The crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy, a little chewy, and built to hold plenty of cheese and toppings. It is a dependable pick when you want an unfussy carryout night or need a couple of big pies for a team gathering.
02
Best for delivery and specials
Romeo's Pizza
East Side Of Lagrange • Modern Chain Pizzeria With Bold Toppings • Best For Delivery Deals
A local outpost of the Ohio-born chain known for sweet-leaning sauce, creative specialty pies, and reliable delivery.
Romeo’s in LaGrange gives you more adventurous options than a typical chain, with specialty pies loaded up with toppings, savory-sweet sauce, and thick, edge-to-edge cheese. It is especially handy on busy nights thanks to online ordering, frequent coupons, and consistent delivery times. If you are feeding a crowd that likes variety—from meat-heavy to veggie-focused—this is an easy crowd-pleaser.
03
College-town favorite
Lorenzo's Pizzeria
Downtown Oberlin • Old-School College-Town Pizzeria • Best For A Slice After A Stroll
A long-running Oberlin standby serving hefty slices and whole pies just off the main drag.
Lorenzo’s Pizzeria sits in the heart of downtown Oberlin, making it an easy stop after a walk around campus or a show. Expect a lively, student-heavy crowd, foldable slices, and plenty of topping combinations that skew classic rather than fussy. It is a relaxed, no-rush place to grab a pie, people-watch, and soak in a little college-town energy before heading back toward LaGrange.
04
Best for game-day gatherings
P-Dubs Pizza & Grub
Downtown Wellington • Family-Friendly Pizza And Pub-Style Fare • Best For Families And Groups
A lively Wellington spot where big pizzas share table space with wings, sandwiches, and plenty of TVs.
P-Dubs Pizza & Grub feels built for game nights and casual meetups, with roomy tables, a laid-back crowd, and a menu that goes well beyond pizza. The pies come in generous sizes with crowd-pleasing toppings, and you can round things out with wings or fried appetizers for the table. It is a solid choice when you want to make an evening of it rather than just grab a quick box to go.
05
Worth-the-drive Italian spot
Sorrento Ristorante & Pizzeria
Sheffield Village Corridor • Classic Italian-American Pizzeria And Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
A sit-down Italian spot where the pizza shares the spotlight with pastas, antipasti, and house specialties.
Sorrento’s offers a more leisurely way to enjoy pizza, with table service, wine, and a menu that reads like a greatest-hits of Italian-American comfort food. The pies lean traditional—think crisp yet substantial crusts, balanced sauce, and restrained but flavorful toppings. It is an especially good pick when you want a meal that feels a bit more like a night out than takeout, without venturing too far from LaGrange.