01
Closest hometown option
Charm Pizza Co.
Charm Village • Small-Town Pizzeria And Buffet • Laid-Back Local Hangout
A relaxed village pizza spot with a simple buffet and carryout pies that feel made for weeknights at the lake.
Charm Pizza Co. is the kind of low-key, no-frills shop locals rely on for an easy pizza night after a day on the water or the farm. The buffet is straightforward but satisfying, and the crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy enough for loading up on toppings. It’s close enough to Lake Buckhorn to make grabbing a couple of pies on the way back to the cabin an easy call.
02
Game-day standby
East of Chicago Pizza
Millersburg South Side • Casual Pizza Buffet And Carryout • Best For Big Groups
A roomy, family-friendly East of Chicago outpost known for its buffet and customizable pies that keep groups happy.
On the south side of Millersburg, East of Chicago is a reliable choice when you’ve got a mixed crowd and need plenty of food fast. The buffet lets everyone sample different crusts and toppings, from thick and bready to thinner, crispier pies. It’s a natural fit for larger lake groups, with easy parking and enough seating that you’re not squeezing around a tiny table.
03
Shop-and-slice combo
East of Chicago Pizza Berlin
Berlin Village • Casual Amish Country Pizzeria • Best After A Day Of Shopping
A convenient pizza stop in Berlin where you can wind down with a hot pie after browsing Amish Country shops.
Set right in busy Berlin, this East of Chicago location is handy when your day has been more about antiques and quilt shops than time on the water. The menu runs beyond pizza to include subs, wedges, and salads, making it easy to feed a group with different appetites. Swing by on your way back to Lake Buckhorn to avoid cooking after a full day of exploring.
04
Chain comfort pick
Pizza Hut
North Millersburg • National Chain Dine-In And Carryout • Kid-Pleasing Classic
A familiar dine-in Pizza Hut where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and big booths make it an easy family fallback.
Sometimes you just want something you know, and the Millersburg Pizza Hut fills that role for many Lake Buckhorn regulars. The pan crust and breadsticks are straight out of the childhood playbook, and kids usually know exactly what they want before they sit down. It’s a practical option when you’re in town for groceries and want to tack on a simple, predictable pizza night.
05
Worth-the-drive standout
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Craft Pizza And Wings Spot • Destination-Worthy Pies
A busy, from-scratch pizza shop in Sugarcreek that draws fans from all over Amish Country for its crust, toppings, and wings.
Park Street Pizza is a step up from typical small-town takeout, with thoughtfully made dough, quality toppings, and wings that are as popular as the pies. It does require a bit of a drive from Lake Buckhorn, but many locals make a night of it, pairing pizza with a stroll through Sugarcreek’s quirky Swiss-themed downtown. Call ahead at peak times—this is the one place on the list that regularly feels like a regional destination.