01
Best overall lake pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Along Mahoning Avenue In Lake Milton • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Go-To Lake Crowd Choice
Reliable, generously topped pies that are easy to grab on your way to or from the lake.
This is the spot locals think of first when someone says “pizza by the lake.” The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with plenty of cheese and classic toppings that travel well to a boat, campsite, or rental. Seating is limited, so most people call ahead and pick up along Mahoning Avenue before heading back to the water.
02
Best for familiar favorites
Pizza Hut
Newton Falls Commercial Strip • Family-Friendly National Chain • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
Classic pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and breadsticks that make planning a low-stress group meal simple.
If you’ve got a mixed group and want something everybody recognizes, the Newton Falls Pizza Hut is a safe bet. The menu runs from pan pizzas to wings and desserts, with plenty of combo deals for feeding a cabin full of people. It’s an easy stop on the way back from errands in town, and a solid choice when you don’t feel like debating where to order from.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Near Downtown Newton Falls • Fast Delivery Pizza Chain • Quick Delivery Option
Customizable pies and specialty pizzas with delivery that reaches many Lake Milton-area addresses.
Domino’s in Newton Falls is the go-to when hunger hits later in the evening and you’d rather stay in. The online ordering makes it easy to build your own pie, choose crust styles, and tack on extras like Parmesan Bread Bites or wings. It’s especially handy for lake rentals and campgrounds that fall within the local delivery zone.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza
Austintown Kirk Road Area • Old-School Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Regional Favorite
Thick, cheese-forward squares that show off the area’s signature pizza style.
If you’re up for a short drive, Wedgewood Fernando’s in Austintown is a must-try for serious pizza fans. The pies are cut in hearty squares with a crisp bottom, generous cheese, and a punchy red sauce that locals swear by. Call ahead during peak hours; the shop draws steady traffic from all over the Mahoning Valley.
05
Best sit-down option
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Austintown Mahoning Avenue Corridor • Casual Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Family Dinner Pick
A full Italian menu plus substantial pizzas, ideal when you want a proper sit-down meal off the lake.
Belleria in Austintown is where you go when the group wants pizza but also Italian comfort food like pasta, salads, and sandwiches. The pizzas lean hearty, with a hand-tossed crust and toppings piled on generously. It’s a comfortable, family-friendly spot for lingering over a meal before heading back to Lake Milton for the evening.