01
Best overall pick
Crossroads Pizza
Malvern, Just West Of Lake Mohawk • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
Hearty, well-topped pies and friendly service make Crossroads Pizza the first call for many Lake Mohawk regulars.
Crossroads is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to grab a pizza near the lake. The crust is sturdy without being heavy, with plenty of cheese and toppings that run right to the edge. It’s an easy stop on the way in or out of town, and a reliable choice when you’re ordering for a mixed crowd.
02
Retro pizza parlor charm
Pizza Parlor II
Carrollton, Southeast Of The Lake • Old-School Dine-In Pizza Parlor • Best For Families And Groups
A Carrollton mainstay with a nostalgic feel, Pizza Parlor II serves classic pies that suit everything from team dinners to family nights out.
If you like your pizza with a side of small-town nostalgia, Pizza Parlor II delivers the right atmosphere. Expect generous portions, classic topping combos, and a laid-back dining room where nobody rushes you out. It’s a smart pick when you’ve got a big group and want to linger over a few pitchers and pans of pizza.
03
Big-flavor carryout pies
Gionino's Pizzeria
Minerva, North Of Lake Mohawk • Takeout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Takeout And Delivery
Known for bold seasoning and generous toppings, Gionino’s is a go-to when you want a flavor-packed pie to bring back to the lake.
Gionino’s leans into big, savory flavors—think garlicky crusts, loaded specialty pizzas, and hearty sides. It’s geared toward takeout and delivery, which makes it ideal when you’d rather stay on the deck and watch the sunset. Call ahead on busy evenings; locals know this is an easy, satisfying option for feeding a hungry group.
04
Square-cut crowd-pleaser
Kraus' Pizza
Minerva, Along The Main Strip • Ohio-Style Pan And Sheet Pizza Shop • Great For Game Nights
Kraus’ specializes in square-cut, sheet-style pies that are perfect for sharing around a card table or during the big game.
This is the place to order when you’ve got a lot of people to feed and don’t want to overthink it. The classic Ohio-style crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and small square slices make it easy for everyone to grab a piece (or three). Add a couple of their classic topping combos and you’ve got a low-fuss, high-satisfaction spread for the cabin.
05
Reliable national favorite
Pizza Hut
Carrollton Shopping Corridor • Casual Chain Pizza Restaurant • Best When You Want Something Familiar
For pan pizzas and breadsticks exactly the way you expect them, the Carrollton Pizza Hut is the familiar option close to the lake.
Sometimes you just want a pizza you know by heart, and the Carrollton Pizza Hut fills that role for many Lake Mohawk visitors. It’s an easy choice when you’re traveling with kids or picky eaters who know their favorite crust and toppings. Order ahead, swing through town, and head back to the water with boxes stacked in the back seat.