01
Closest to the lake
Valley Pizza Co.
Near Lake Tomahawk In Negley • Small-Town Takeout And Delivery Shop • Lake-Day Staple
The go-to pie when you want hot, cheesy pizza just a few minutes from the water.
Valley Pizza Co. is the nearest dedicated pizzeria to Lake Tomahawk, making it an easy choice after a day on the boat or at the beach. The menu leans classic—think sturdy crusts, lots of cheese, and generous toppings that hold up well to takeout and delivery. Call ahead before you head up from the lake and you can usually time it just right for a quick pickup.
02
Best for classic trays
Pizza Joe's
East Palestine • Regional Chain With Hometown Feel • Comfort-Food Favorite
Square-cut pies, familiar flavors, and a steady, reliable option in East Palestine.
Pizza Joe's in East Palestine is a popular stop for those who grew up with the brand’s soft, bready crust and thick layer of cheese. The square-cut slices make it easy to feed a group back at the cabin or campsite. It is also a handy place to mix pizza with wings or subs when everyone is craving something a little different.
03
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
Lisbon • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Build-Your-Own Crowd-Pleaser
A flexible spot where you can pick your crust style and topping combos to match any group.
East of Chicago in Lisbon gives Lake Tomahawk visitors a wide range of choices, from pan and thin crusts to heavier specialty pies. It is a practical option when you are driving through town and want something familiar but customizable. Large orders and frequent specials also make it attractive for families and bigger lake groups.
04
Best for dine-in with kids
Pizza Hut
Columbiana • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Sit-Down Classic
A comfortable, predictable stop with booths, breadsticks, and plenty of space for families.
The Columbiana Pizza Hut offers the full sit-down experience, which can be a welcome change after days of grilling or grab-and-go food at the lake. Pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and familiar sides keep kids and less adventurous eaters happy. It is an easy meeting point if your group is spread between town and the lake.
05
Best for takeout specials
Giorgio's Oven Fresh Pizza Co.
Columbiana • Neighborhood Carryout Pizzeria • Value-Focused Option
Oven-fresh pies and regular specials that work well when you are feeding a crowd on a budget.
Giorgio's in Columbiana is a handy choice if you are stocking up on pizza before heading back out to Lake Tomahawk. The crust is designed to travel well, and the menu usually includes combo deals that stretch your dollar. Call in a mix of classic and specialty pies and you will have enough to keep everyone at the cabin satisfied.