01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria (Lakemore / Ellet)
Canton Road Corridor • Neighborhood Carryout And Delivery Shop • Local Favorite For Takeout
A go‑to for consistent, cheesy pies and chicken just a few minutes from the heart of Lakemore.
If you ask around Lakemore where people actually order from on a busy weeknight, this Gionino’s location comes up fast. The crust is sturdy without being heavy, the cheese is generous, and the toppings are piled on in true Northeast Ohio fashion. It’s an easy first choice for families who want dependable pizza, wings, and jojo potatoes without driving into downtown Akron.
02
Classic East Side slice
Regina's Pizza
East Akron • Old-School East Side Pizzeria • Best For Big, Shareable Pies
A long‑running Akron favorite turning out saucy, cheese‑blanketed pies that feed a crowd.
Regina’s has that lived‑in local feel: simple booths, big ovens, and regulars who have been ordering the same pie for years. The pizza leans hearty, with a slightly thicker crust, a tomato‑forward sauce, and lots of cheese that browns nicely at the edges. It’s the kind of place you call when the game is on, the family is over, and you need a couple of big, no‑nonsense pizzas everyone will recognize and demolish.
03
Retro Italian standout
Lembo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Tallmadge • Sit‑Down Italian Restaurant With Classic Pies • Best For Sit‑Down Family Dinners
A throwback red‑sauce spot where pizza shares the spotlight with generously portioned Italian comfort food.
Lembo’s feels like stepping into a vintage family restaurant, complete with dark wood, red sauce, and friendly servers who know the regulars. The pizza comes on a slightly thicker crust, with ample toppings and that classic Midwestern tavern‑style look. It’s a smart choice when you want pizza on the table but also crave pasta, salads, and a more relaxed, lingering dinner just up the road from Lakemore.
04
Akron classic pick
Guiseppe's Pizza
North Akron • Classic Akron Pizzeria • Best For Old‑School Flavor
A long‑time Akron staple known for crispy‑edged pies and a loyal neighborhood following.
Guiseppe’s is the kind of spot people grow up with and keep coming back to even after they move across town. The pizzas have a well‑baked crust with a satisfying crunch, nicely balanced sauce, and toppings that are finely chopped and evenly scattered. From Lakemore it’s a bit of a drive, but locals make the trip when they’re in the mood for a nostalgic, Akron‑style pie that tastes like a Friday night tradition.
05
Late-night campus favorite
Totally Baked Pizza
Downtown Akron / University Area • Casual Slice Shop And Delivery Spot • Best Late‑Night Option
A laid‑back shop popular with students for big slices, inventive toppings, and late hours.
Totally Baked is a fun contrast to the more traditional parlors around Lakemore, with a menu that leans into creative topping combos and loaded specialty pies. Slices are substantial and designed to satisfy after a game, concert, or night out downtown. It’s a good move when you’re already in Akron or don’t mind the drive for something a little more playful than your standard pepperoni-and-cheese order.