01
Best overall pick
DiCarlo's Pizza - Bridgeport
Bridgeport Just West Of The River • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Local Classic
This Bridgeport outpost of DiCarlo’s is the go-to for hot trays of Ohio Valley–style pizza topped with cold cheese right out of the oven.
DiCarlo’s in Bridgeport is often the first name locals throw out when someone in Lansing mentions pizza. The operation is straightforward—order your tray or slices, wait for the crisp, lightly sauced crust to come out, then watch as a generous layer of cheese goes on after baking. The result is nostalgic, slightly messy, and exactly what you want for a casual night in or an easy pickup on the way back through town.
02
Best for families
DeFelice Bros. Pizza - Martins Ferry
Martins Ferry Hillside • Family Pizzeria And Delivery Spot • Best For Families
DeFelice Bros. in Martins Ferry delivers crowd-pleasing pies with plenty of topping choices and a slightly thicker, chewier crust.
Just a short drive north of Lansing, DeFelice Bros. in Martins Ferry is built for family dinners and team pizza nights. The crust has enough heft to hold generous toppings, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations, without feeling heavy. With reliable delivery, roomy takeout orders, and prices that work well for groups, it is a practical standby when you are feeding a table full of kids or friends.
03
Classic sit-down option
Figaretti's Restaurant
Wheeling Hillside Above Town • Old-School Italian Dining Room • Best For A Sit-Down Meal
Figaretti’s in Wheeling is an old-school Italian spot where the pizzas share the stage with hearty pastas, red sauce, and bottles of wine.
If you want more of a night out than a quick slice, Figaretti’s gives you that cozy, red-sauce-Italian experience along with solid pizza. The pies come with a nicely browned cheese layer, a flavorful sauce, and toppings that lean classic rather than trendy. It is the place to go when you want to linger over a pizza, salad, and maybe a plate of spaghetti instead of rushing back to the car with a box.
04
Quick-grab favorite
DiCarlo's Pizza - Downtown Wheeling
Downtown Wheeling • Counter-Service Slice Shop • Late-Night And Downtown Pick
The downtown Wheeling DiCarlo’s keeps the Ohio Valley square tradition alive with fast slices that are ideal before or after a night in town.
This downtown DiCarlo’s is all about efficiency: step up to the counter, call your order, and in a few minutes you are biting into a hot square with cool cheese on top. It is a handy stop if you are in Wheeling for a show, a game, or errands and want something quick that still feels distinctly local. For Lansing residents, it makes a convenient pizza fix when a trip across the river is already on the agenda.
05
Best for delivery and custom orders
Vocelli Pizza - St. Clairsville
St. Clairsville Retail Strip • Delivery-Focused Chain Outpost • Best For Big Groups
Vocelli’s St. Clairsville store turns out consistent, customizable pizzas with plenty of crust, sauce, and topping options for larger orders.
When you need a lot of pizza to show up at once—think parties, game days, or late work nights—Vocelli in St. Clairsville is a dependable choice. The menu runs from simple one-topping pies to specialty combinations, with options for different crusts and sizes, plus wings and sides to round things out. It is not as nostalgic as the old neighborhood shops, but its range of choices and straightforward delivery make it a useful part of the rotation for households in and around Lansing.