Laurelville may be a small village, but it sits in the middle of a surprisingly strong pizza corridor in Hocking County and the Hocking Hills. Within a short drive you can find everything from laid-back small-town slices to busy post-hike spots feeding trail-worn visitors. These five picks cover both in-town standbys and road-trip-worthy destinations locals happily recommend.
Classic, no-frills pies and friendly service right in the heart of Laurelville.
If you want pizza without leaving the village, L & J is the obvious choice. The menu sticks to the basics—think loaded pepperoni, sausage, and veggie pies—but portions are generous and prices stay reasonable. It feels like the kind of place where the staff quickly learns your regular order.
Hearty stone-baked pizzas and subs a short drive from Laurelville, right in Hocking Hills country.
Papa Dino's sits in South Bloomingville, making it an easy swing after hiking Old Man's Cave, Rock House, or Ash Cave. The crust runs on the thicker, chewy side, built to hold plenty of cheese and toppings. It’s the kind of satisfying, carb-heavy meal that hits perfectly after a long day on the trails.
A busy Logan staple known for loaded pies, wings, and enough variety to keep everyone at the table happy.
If your group is split between plain cheese lovers and pile-it-high pizza fans, Pizza Crossing is an easy compromise. The toppings are abundant, the cheese pull is serious, and the menu stretches into subs, salads, and wings. It’s a bit of a drive from Laurelville, but plenty of locals consider it worth the trip, especially for feeding a crowd.
A quirky, pirate-themed spot turning out generous pies near the Hocking Hills attractions.
Capt. Ron's leans into its theme, which keeps kids entertained while you wait for your order. The pizzas are straightforward and hearty, built on a crust that lands between thin and thick with plenty of cheese on top. It’s a relaxed, vacation-town kind of place that pairs naturally with a day of zip-lining or hiking nearby.
Simple, satisfying pies and subs just up the road in Adelphi, ideal for taking back to a cabin or campsite.
Steve's Pizza keeps things straightforward: solid crust, familiar toppings, and fast service. Its location in Adelphi makes it a natural stop if you’re heading back toward cabins or homes north of Laurelville. Call ahead for carryout and you can be back on the road with dinner in hand in just a few minutes.