01
Best overall pick
Sunrise Inn
Downtown Warren • Old-School Tavern Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Warren institution pouring out square-cut pies with a loyal following and a lively, lived-in atmosphere.[3]
Sunrise Inn is one of those places that comes up immediately when you ask Warren locals where to get pizza, thanks to its long history and consistently hearty pies.[3] The crust runs on the thicker side, with plenty of cheese and toppings that lean classic rather than trendy, making it ideal when you want comfort pizza in a casual dining-room or bar setting.[3] It’s a solid all-rounder for groups, with pastas and wings if someone in the crew somehow isn’t in a pizza mood.[3]
02
Best for specialty pies
Red Plum Pizza & Pasta
North Warren • Italian Pizza And Pasta Spot • Best For Variety
A polished but relaxed Italian spot known for well-reviewed pizzas and a deep menu of pastas and appetizers.[3]
Red Plum Pizza & Pasta gives you a slightly more modern take on the local pizza scene, with specialty pies and Italian entrées that go beyond basic pepperoni.[3] It’s a good pick when you want a sit-down dinner, since you can start with fried apps or salad, split a large pizza, and still have the option of pasta or chicken dishes for anyone craving something different.[3] The dining room is comfortable without feeling fussy, making it an easy choice for date night or a nicer family meal.[3]
03
Best neighborhood spot
Salvatore's
Central Warren • Classic Italian Pizzeria • Best For Families
A family-friendly Italian restaurant serving generous pizzas alongside subs, wings, and red-sauce favorites.[3]
Salvatore's hits that sweet spot between pizzeria and full Italian restaurant, so you can build a meal around pizza without feeling locked in.[3] The pies come with a nicely browned cheese layer and plenty of topping options, and the broader menu—think pasta, sandwiches, and wings—works well for mixed groups or kids who like to graze.[3] It feels like the kind of place regulars return to weekly, which is exactly what you want from a neighborhood pizza joint just a short drive from Leavittsburg.[3]
04
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza (Mahoning Ave NW)
Mahoning Avenue Nw Corridor • Chain Takeout And Delivery Pizza • Best For Quick Delivery
A go-to chain location for Leavittsburg-area delivery, with consistent pies, lots of deals, and late-weeknight hours.[2]
When convenience matters more than ambience, this Domino’s on Mahoning Avenue NW is one of the easiest ways to get pizza to a Leavittsburg address.[2] The menu covers the usual hand-tossed and pan pizzas, stuffed cheesy breads, wings, and desserts, so it’s simple to feed a crowd without overthinking it.[2] Online ordering and frequent discounts make it especially handy for busy weeknights, game days, or last-minute cravings.[2]
05
Best for pan pizza cravings
Pizza Hut (Mahoning Ave)
West Warren • Casual Chain Pizza Restaurant • Comfort Pick
A familiar Pizza Hut location serving thick pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and wings within a short drive of Leavittsburg.[2]
If you grew up on Pizza Hut, this Mahoning Avenue spot scratches that nostalgic itch with its buttery pan crusts and classic red-roof flavors.[2] It’s close enough to Leavittsburg for an easy carryout run, and it also offers delivery for nights when you’d rather stay home.[2] Between the build-your-own options, specialty pies, and shareable sides, it’s a straightforward, comfort-food choice when you want something predictable and satisfying.[2]