01
Best overall pick
R Pizza Place
Downtown Columbiana • Made-From-Scratch Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy small-town shop known for hand-crafted pies and a friendly, no-rush atmosphere.
Locals make the short drive to Columbiana for R Pizza Place when they want a classic, from-scratch pie instead of a chain slice. The crust has a satisfying chew, the sauce leans flavorful rather than overly sweet, and the toppings are piled on generously without getting greasy. It is the kind of spot where staff remember regulars and a couple of large pizzas will easily feed a family or small group.
02
Old-school option
Belleria Pizza & Italian
Columbiana Retail Strip • Italian-American Pizza And Pasta Joint • Best For Red-Sauce Cravings
Hearty pizzas and classic Italian dinners make this a go-to when you want more than just a slice.
Belleria brings a traditional Italian-American menu to the Columbiana strip, with pizza sharing menu space with baked pastas and chicken parm. The pies tend to be saucier and cheesier, with a crust that holds up well under heavier toppings. It is an easy choice when some of the group wants pizza and others are in the mood for a sit-down pasta dinner.
03
Easy takeout choice
Pizza Joe's
Near Central Columbiana • Takeout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Quick Carryout
A dependable stop for customizable pies, wings, and sides when you need dinner on the table fast.
Pizza Joe's is built around convenience, with a menu tailored to easy phone-in or online orders and fast turnaround. The crust runs on the slightly thicker side of hand-tossed, which holds toppings and extra cheese well for the drive back to Leetonia. Add in wings, breadsticks, and a few dessert options and it becomes a one-stop shop for a casual game night spread.
04
Most familiar name
Pizza Hut
Columbiana Main Corridor • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Familiar Flavors
Classic pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and combo deals make this an easy crowd-pleaser.
For many families around Leetonia, the Columbiana Pizza Hut is the default choice when everyone wants something predictable. The menu covers the chain staples—from thick, buttery pan crusts to stuffed crust and loaded specialty pies—plus wings and pasta. It is especially handy for feeding a mixed group of kids and adults who all know exactly what they like from the national brand.
05
Worth-the-drive delivery
Gionino's Pizzeria
North Side Of Salem • Neighborhood Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Big Group Orders
Generous toppings and big-party specials make this Salem standby popular for gatherings.
Gionino's in Salem is a bit farther from Leetonia, but many locals consider it worth the extra miles for the loaded pies and deals on larger orders. The crust is sturdy and slightly crisp, which helps the pizza travel well, and the topping combinations range from straightforward pepperoni to heavier specialty options. Pair a couple of sheet pizzas with their well-known fried chicken or JoJo potatoes and you have an easy solution for feeding a crowd.