01
Best in-town classic
Pizzeria
Downtown Leipsic • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
A straightforward, no-fuss pizza joint that feels like Leipsic’s built-in comfort-food stop.
This Main Street spot is exactly what you want from a village pizzeria: friendly staff, reliably hot pies, and portions that won’t leave anyone hungry. Expect classic Midwest-style crust, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings done right. It’s the easy choice when you want to stay close to home and keep everyone at the table happy.
02
Best for group orders
Pisanello's Pizza
Central Ottawa • Old-School Carryout And Dine-In Shop • Best For Families And Teams
A long-running Ottawa favorite that’s tailor-made for sharing big pizzas and breadsticks with a crowd.
Pisanello’s leans into generous toppings, sturdy crust, and big pans that make feeding a family or ball team simple. The menu stays classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and veggie combos—so even picky eaters can find a favorite. Call ahead on busy nights; locals know this is an easy win for casual gatherings.
03
Best nostalgic slice
Jac & Do's Pizza
Ottawa Main Drag • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Parlor • Classic Small-Town Slice Spot
A relaxed Ottawa standby where the pizza tastes like the one you grew up with.
Jac & Do’s serves the kind of slightly crispy, cheesy pies that have anchored Ohio towns for decades. The room is unfussy and comfortable, perfect for lingering over a pizza, salad, and a pitcher of pop. It’s a solid pick when you want something familiar, filling, and pleasantly old-school after a day out.
04
Best build-your-own options
East of Chicago Pizza
Columbus Grove Village Center • Casual Chain Pizzeria With Buffet Feel • Best For Variety And Customization
A flexible option where you can pick your crust, pile on toppings, and keep everyone’s order just the way they like it.
East of Chicago in Columbus Grove is known for its thick, airy pan crust and customizable specialty pies. With options ranging from traditional pepperoni to loaded taco or chicken-bacon combinations, it’s easy to mix and match for a group. It’s a practical choice when you’re driving with a carful of hungry friends coming through the county.
05
Best worth-the-drive outing
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Findlay Shopping Corridor • Lively Sports-Bar-Style Pizza Grill • Best For Game Days And Bigger Nights Out
A bigger, busier destination with hearty pizzas, plenty of TVs, and a full menu beyond just pies.
If you’re up for a short drive, Beer Barrel in Findlay turns pizza night into more of an outing. Their pizzas come loaded with toppings and share the menu with wings, burgers, and salads, making it easy to please a mixed group. Pair a specialty pie with a game on the big screens and you’ve got a solid weekend stop that still feels connected to the local northwest Ohio scene.