01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Classic
A serious, wood-fired pizza shop in downtown Bellefontaine that’s worth planning a night around.
Six Hundred Downtown is the spot locals point to when they talk about truly standout pizza in Logan County. Expect blistered, chewy crusts, high-quality toppings, and a menu that ranges from classic margherita to more creative specialty pies. It’s a sit-down place with a lively small-town downtown feel, so it works just as well for date night as it does for a family outing.
02
Best for fast delivery
Domino's Pizza Bellefontaine
East Bellefontaine • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
Go-to choice when you want consistent pizza, lots of topping options, and quick delivery out toward Lewistown.
This Domino's location is a staple for weeknight dinners, game nights, and late study sessions. The menu is broad, with everything from build-your-own pies to specialty combinations, plus wings, bread twists, and desserts. It’s especially handy if you’re staying near Lewistown and want hot pizza brought to your door without much planning.
03
Best for families and teams
Pizza Hut Bellefontaine
South Bellefontaine • Casual Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families
Classic pan pizza and big booths make this a comfortable choice for families, birthday parties, and sports teams.
The Bellefontaine Pizza Hut leans into the familiar formula: thick pan crusts, stuffed-crust options, and plenty of classics like pepperoni and supreme. It’s one of the easier spots to bring a crowd, thanks to roomy seating and shareable combos. If you’re coming in from a game or a day at Indian Lake with kids in tow, this is a low-stress place to refuel.
04
Best budget-friendly option
Little Caesars Bellefontaine
North Bellefontaine • Carryout Chain With Hot-And-Ready Pies • Best Value
Fast, no-frills carryout pizza that’s easy on the wallet and perfect when you need food now.
Little Caesars in Bellefontaine is all about speed and price: walk in, grab a hot-and-ready pepperoni or cheese pizza, and you’re back on the road in minutes. It’s a popular stop for families heading back toward Lewistown after errands or practices. Add in their crazy bread and occasional specialty pies, and you’ve got an easy way to feed a group without much planning.
05
Best lake-day grab-and-go
Casey's Lakeview
Near Indian Lake • Convenience-Store Pizza Counter • Grab-And-Go Choice
Surprisingly solid pizza from a convenience store, ideal for quick stops on the way to or from Indian Lake.
Casey’s has built a quiet following for its Midwest-style pizza, and the Lakeview location is no exception. You can order whole pies or grab slices while you’re fueling up, stocking the cooler, or heading back from the water. It’s not fancy, but for a hot, cheesy pizza that travels well back to Lewistown or the lake house, it does the job nicely.