01
Best overall pick
Fox's Pizza Den
Woodsfield • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A reliable stop in Woodsfield for generously topped pies and friendly, no-rush service.
Fox's Pizza Den is the place locals point to first when you ask about pizza near Lewisville, thanks to its crisp-edged crusts and hearty toppings. The menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, plus stromboli and wedges if you want something different. It is an easy, low-key choice whether you are grabbing takeout on the way home or sitting down after a Monroe County ballgame.
02
Best sit-down meal
Traditions Family Restaurant & Pizza
Woodsfield Courthouse Area • Family-Style Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Families
Comfort-food mains share the menu with solid, crowd-pleasing pizzas in a family-friendly setting.
At Traditions, pizza is part of a bigger small-town restaurant experience, with plenty of booths and a menu that keeps everyone at the table happy. The pizzas lean classic Midwest: soft, chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings that appeal to kids and grandparents alike. It is a good pick when you want pizza but also need options like dinners, sandwiches, and salads on the table.
03
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
New Martinsville Riverfront Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Best For Delivery
A dependable choice for quick, customizable pizzas delivered out toward the Lewisville side of the river.
When it is too late or too cold to make the drive and sit down somewhere, the New Martinsville Domino's is often the most practical answer. You get the familiar build-your-own and specialty pies, plus extras like wings and sandwiches, with online ordering that makes repeat orders easy. It is not the most unique pizza around, but for consistent delivery out into the hills, it is hard to beat.
04
Best for pan pizza
Pizza Hut
Caldwell I-77 Corridor • Classic Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Group-Friendly Choice
A familiar stop off the highway for thick, buttery pan pizzas and roomy seating for groups.
If you like a nostalgic dine-in pizza night, the Caldwell Pizza Hut scratches that itch with its pan pizzas, breadsticks, and big soda pitchers. It is a convenient meeting point if friends and family are coming from different directions around Monroe and Noble counties. Call ahead for larger orders and you can feed a crowd without much fuss.
05
Most distinctive style
DiCarlo's Pizza
St. Clairsville Shopping Strip • Ohio Valley-Style Pizza Shop • Worth-The-Drive Experience
A classic Ohio Valley slice spot where the hot crust and sauce meet cold cheese and toppings at the counter.
DiCarlo's is a regional institution, and the St. Clairsville shop is one of the closer spots if you are willing to make a drive for something different. Pizzas come cut in squares with sauce and crust baked first, then a snowfall of cold cheese and toppings added right before serving. It is a simple, addictive style that many Monroe County families make a special trip for when they want more than their usual go-to pie.