01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Lima Near I-75 • Bustling Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Game Days
A lively spot where big, shareable pizzas and a long tap list make it an easy choice for meeting up with friends or family.
Beer Barrel is the kind of place Lima locals suggest when you say you want pizza and a full sit-down meal in one stop. The menu leans into hefty specialty pies, from loaded meat combinations to veggie-topped options, alongside wings and sandwiches. TVs, a busy bar, and roomy booths make it especially good for catching a game or gathering a crowd without feeling cramped.
02
Carryout standout
Fat Jack's Pizza
North Lima Along Cable Road • Classic Carryout And Delivery Joint • Go-To Option For Late-Night Cravings
A long-running local chain known for generous toppings, square-cut pies, and reliable delivery when you just want solid pizza at home.
Fat Jack's is woven into the routine of many Lima households, especially for busy nights and game-day delivery. The crust is sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and the square-cut style makes it easy to feed a crowd without a lot of ceremony. Add in breadsticks and wings and you have a one-call solution for casual get-togethers or nights when nobody wants to cook.
03
Long-time local classic
TJ's Pizza
Elida Just Northwest Of Lima • Retro Counter-Service Pizzeria • Old-School Local Favorite
A no-frills spot that has been turning out consistently good, classic pizzas for decades to loyal Allen County regulars.
TJ's feels like the kind of pizza place that could only exist in a small Midwestern community: straightforward, friendly, and focused on the pie. Locals come for the familiar flavor of their thin, slightly chewy crust and balanced sauce-and-cheese combo that hasn’t changed much over the years. It’s an easy detour from Lima when you want a low-key pickup or a simple dine-in meal away from the busier corridors.
04
Pizza and grinders go-to
Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders
West Lima Near The Shopping Corridor • Pizza And Grinders Shop • Best For A Quick, Casual Dinner
A casual counter-service spot where you can split the table between made-to-order pizzas and hefty oven-baked grinders.
Bellacino's works well when not everyone at the table is set on pizza, thanks to its lineup of hot grinders alongside personal and shareable pies. The crust is slightly thicker and more bready than some of Lima’s old-school shops, making it filling without being heavy. Its location near shopping and big-box stores makes it a convenient stop after errands or before a movie night.
05
Underrated neighborhood gem
Curly's Pizza & Subs
South Lima Neighborhood Strip • Neighborhood Pizza And Sub Shop • Best Kept Neighborhood Secret
A laid-back, locally minded shop turning out hearty pizzas and subs that feel tailor-made for low-key weeknights.
Curly's leans into the small-shop charm, with friendly service and pies that prioritize substance over flash. The crust has a satisfying chew, and toppings are applied with a generous hand, making even a basic pepperoni feel like a splurge. It’s the sort of place nearby residents keep in their back pocket for quick pickups, casual family dinners, and Friday night traditions.