01
Neighborhood standby
Joseppi's Pizza - Lincoln Village
West Broad Street Corridor • Classic Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Long-running Columbus-style shop turning out party-cut pies that feel made for west side family pizza night.
Joseppi's is the prototypical Columbus thin-crust joint, with edge-to-edge toppings, plenty of cheese, and that nostalgic party-cut presentation. It's a go-to for straightforward pepperoni, sausage, and deluxe pies that land hot and fast, whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout. If you want a no-drama, reliably good pizza that tastes like the west side, this is the place.
02
Solid delivery choice
Casa Di Pizza
Near Mckinley Avenue And West Side Industrial Strip • Hearty Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Delivery Nights
Generous toppings and substantial crust make Casa Di Pizza a strong pick when you want a filling pie brought to your door.
Casa Di Pizza leans into big, satisfying pies with plenty of cheese and toppings, ideal when you're feeding a crowd. The menu usually runs the gamut from classic pepperoni and meat-heavy combinations to veggie-focused options and wings on the side. It's a dependable choice when you want the game on, the oven off, and a couple of big boxes arriving right on schedule.
03
Family-friendly pick
Flyers Pizza & Subs - West Broad
Just West Of Lincoln Village On West Broad • Casual Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families
A west side staple where thin-crust pies, subs, and wings make it easy to please a mixed group.
Flyers pairs crisp-edged, square-cut pizza with a full lineup of subs, salads, and wings, which is a lifesaver when not everyone at the table wants the same thing. The atmosphere is relaxed and kid-friendly, and takeout is streamlined for quick weeknight pickups. It's the sort of place locals rely on for birthday parties, post-game dinners, and easy Friday-night spreads.
04
Chain done right
Donatos Pizza - West Broad Street
West Broad Near Westland Area • Well-Known Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Classic Pepperoni
Crisp, edge-to-edge pepperoni and predictable quality make this Donatos a reliable west side workhorse.
If your ideal Columbus pizza is a thin, crispy crust buried under overlapping pepperoni, the West Broad Donatos delivers exactly that. It's not the most adventurous spot on the list, but the consistency, quick service, and familiar flavors are hard to beat when you're ordering for an office lunch or a busy weeknight. Online ordering and fast carryout make it especially convenient for Lincoln Village residents.
05
Worth-the-drive option
Massey's Pizza - Hilliard-Rome
Hilliard-Rome Road Commercial Strip • Old-School Columbus Pizza Joint • Best For Classic Tavern-Style Pies
A short hop from Lincoln Village, Massey's is where crispy tavern-style crust and loaded toppings feel like a treat night upgrade.
Massey's leans into the old-school Columbus playbook: cracker-thin crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that reach every corner of the square-cut slices. The Hilliard-Rome location is surrounded by big-box shopping, so it's an easy stop after errands or before heading home. When you want something a bit more indulgent than your usual delivery order, this is an appealing detour.