01
Best overall pick
Depot Pizza
Downtown Fremont • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizzeria • Go-To Spot For Classic Pies And A Pitcher
A Fremont staple with crisp, square-cut pizza and a laid-back, hometown bar feel.
Locals have been coming to Depot Pizza for years for its thin, crackery crust and generous toppings that hit the sweet spot between greasy and comforting. The vibe is pure small-town Ohio: friendly regulars, no-frills booths, and pizza that’s best shared with a cold drink after a long day. It’s an easy choice when you want a classic pie and don’t mind a few minutes’ drive from Lindsey.
02
Game-day favorite
Cameo Pizza
North Fremont • Local-Chain Pizzeria With A Big Menu • Best For Big Groups And Delivery
A crowd-pleasing spot known for loaded specialty pies, wings, and group-friendly deals.
Cameo Pizza leans into the “something for everyone” approach, with specialty pizzas piled high, plenty of sides, and easy ordering for game nights or birthday gatherings. The crust has that slightly chewy, Midwest comfort factor, and the topping combinations get creative without feeling gimmicky. If you’re feeding a mixed crew coming in from Lindsey, Fremont, and Clyde, this is an easy, low-stress pick.
03
Custom-topping standout
Pisanello's Pizza
West Fremont • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Customizable Pies And Subs
A flexible, build-your-own favorite with solid crust, fresh toppings, and hearty subs.
Pisanello’s is the kind of place where regulars know exactly how they like their pizza, down to the sauce level and topping mix. The crust strikes a nice balance between soft and crisp, and the staff does not skimp on cheese or toppings. Add in subs, salads, and easy carryout, and it becomes a reliable choice when you’re picking up dinner on your way back through Fremont to Lindsey.
04
Small-town classic
Pizza House
Clyde • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizza Restaurant • Worth-The-Drive Thin-Crust
A Clyde institution with nostalgic dine-in vibes and well-loved thin-crust pies.
Pizza House feels like stepping into the kind of family spot every small town hopes to have: cozy booths, friendly service, and pizza that tastes like childhood Friday nights. Their thin crust is a local talking point—light, crisp, and sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings. If you’re in Lindsey and don’t mind a short drive east, it’s a relaxed place to linger over a pie and a couple of refills of soda.
05
Delivery workhorse
Marco's Pizza
East Fremont • National Chain With Consistent Pies • Most Reliable Fast Delivery
A chain standby that delivers consistent, cheesy pizzas and sides when you just need it to be easy.
Marco’s in Fremont is the dependable option for nights when no one wants to cook and you want your order to arrive exactly as expected. Their dough has a soft, bready chew, the sauce leans a little garlicky, and the cheese coverage is reliably heavy. It may not be a special-occasion destination, but for Lindsey households looking for quick delivery and predictable comfort pizza, it earns its spot on the shortlist.