Lisbon’s pizza scene is small but surprisingly varied, anchored by a couple of old-school shops locals swear by. Within a short drive, you’ll find regional chains and sports-bar pies that round out the options for busy weeknights and game days. Whether you’re craving a thick, cheesy classic or a big box for a crowd, these picks cover the essentials.
Thick, cheesy pies with a sweet red sauce that locals drive back home for.
Open since the early 1960s, Mary's is the spot most Lisbon folks name first when you ask about pizza. The signature order is a thick-crust pie with their sweet, meaty red sauce and a heavy blanket of provolone. Expect a straightforward, no-frills shop that’s busiest on weekend evenings, so calling ahead is smart.
Hand-tossed pies, big party cuts, and plenty of kid-pleasing sides right off the village square.
Fox’s is the kind of place where a team, a birthday group, or the whole family can split a couple of big, loaded pizzas without breaking the bank. The menu leans into comfort classics—think hand-tossed specialty pies, wedges, wings, and hoagies. It’s an easy walk from the square, with portions built for sharing.
Pan and specialty pizzas with hearty crusts, built for carryout and delivery on busy nights.
When you just need a hot box of pizza on the table fast, East of Chicago is a reliable Lisbon standby. Their thicker pan crust and loaded specialty pies make for a filling meal, and there are wings, subs, and salads to round out an order. It’s especially handy for grab-and-go dinners on the way home.
Crispy-crust pizzas, JoJo chicken, and subs that travel well from Columbiana toward Lisbon.
A short drive from Lisbon, Gionino’s in Columbiana is a go-to when you want both pizza and fried chicken in one order. The crust leans crispy with plenty of cheese and toppings, and their JoJo chicken and potato wedges are local favorites. It’s a smart pick when you’re feeding a mixed crowd that doesn’t all want the same thing.
Square-cut pizza, wings, and cold drinks served in a casual, TV-filled dining room.
If you’re willing to make the short drive up to Salem, G’s delivers a classic sports-bar pizza experience. Pies are usually cut tavern-style into small squares, with plenty of options for toppings, plus wings, appetizers, and a solid draft list. It’s the place to settle in for a game, a big group night out, or a late bite after local events.