01
Best overall pick
Little Italy Ristorante
In-Town Lithopolis • Classic Family-Run Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy hometown spot turning out loaded pies, red-sauce classics, and plenty of comfort-food carbs right in Lithopolis.
Locals lean on Little Italy for everything from Friday night pizza to big trays of pasta for family gatherings. The pizza leans classic Midwest—fairly thin, with a sturdy crust and plenty of cheese and toppings. Pair a pie with their garlic bread or a plate of spaghetti, and you’ve got the quintessential small-town Italian meal a short drive or walk from most of Lithopolis.
02
Best for families
Kingy's Pizza Pub
Canal Winchester • Casual Pizza Pub With A Big Menu And Bar • Crowd-Pleaser For Groups
A roomy, old-school pizza pub where you can split a thin-crust pie, grab a beer, and keep kids happy with plenty of menu options.
Just up the road in Canal Winchester, Kingy’s feels like the kind of place everyone in town has a story about. Pizzas come with a crisp, tavern-style crust and classic toppings, alongside wings, subs, and hearty bar food. It’s an easy pick when you’ve got a mixed group and want a relaxed, noisy dining room where nobody has to whisper or dress up.
03
Best for craft beer and pizza
Romero’s Pizza & Brewhouse
Old Town Canal Winchester • Brewpub With House Pizzas And Rotating Taps • Best For Beer Lovers
A Canal Winchester taproom pairing thoughtfully topped pies with a solid craft beer lineup and a laid-back small-town main-street vibe.
Romero’s sits right in the heart of Canal Winchester, making it an easy stop before or after events around the village. The pizza menu leans into specialty combinations and shareable sizes, making it fun to split a couple of pies across the table. With a good mix of local and regional beers on tap, it’s a natural choice for date night or a relaxed evening with friends who want more than just cheese and pepperoni.
04
Best for loaded specialty pies
Romeo’s Pizza
Pickerington • Takeout-Focused Pizzeria With Hefty Toppings • Go-To For Carryout
A reliable nearby chain outpost known for thick, cheesy pies, bold sauces, and specialty combinations built for takeout nights.
When you want to grab pizza on the way home without sacrificing flavor, the Pickerington Romeo’s is a dependable option from the Lithopolis side of town. Crusts run on the thicker, doughier side, which holds up well under generous toppings and a slightly sweeter sauce. It’s especially handy for game days, kids’ sleepovers, or any night when delivery or quick carryout is the priority.
05
Best for crispy thin-crust
Donatos Pizza
Canal Winchester / Gender Rd. • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain Outpost • Quick, Consistent Pick
A classic Central Ohio name serving edge-to-edge thin-crust pizzas that are easy to share and easy to customize.
Donatos is practically synonymous with Columbus-style pizza, and the nearby Canal Winchester location puts it within quick reach of Lithopolis. Expect a very thin, crispy crust, toppings spread all the way to the edge, and those familiar square-cut slices. It’s ideal when you want something light and crunchy or need to feed a group with a couple of large, predictable pies.