01
Best overall pick
Stoney's Pizza & Market
Lockbourne Road, South Side • No-Frills Counter-Service Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A no-frills spot on Lockbourne Road turning out solid, affordable pies with a friendly, talkative crew behind the counter.[1]
Tucked into a small market space, Stoney's focuses on straightforward, generously topped pizzas and quick service that suits nearby neighborhoods and workers on the go.[1] The vibe is old-school south-side Columbus: regulars at the counter, easy small talk, and hot slices boxed up in minutes.[1] If you want a low-key place where the staff remembers you and the pizza tastes like a true neighborhood standby, this is it.[1]
02
Best value for locals
Papa Joe's Pizza
Marion-Franklin Neighborhood • Classic Columbus-Style Takeout Shop • Best Value For Locals
Lockbourne Road's classic corner pizza shop, known for hearty pies, fair prices, and easy carryout or delivery for nearby neighborhoods.[6]
Papa Joe's sits at 1899 Lockbourne Road and feels like the kind of no-nonsense pizza place every neighborhood leans on for weeknight dinners.[6] Expect classic Columbus-style thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and that slightly sweet sauce locals grow up on. Portions are generous, the menu is broad enough for picky eaters, and the staff keeps orders moving even on busy game nights.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Near Obetz And Lockbourne • National Delivery Chain Outpost • Best For Late-Night Delivery
A reliable Domino's outpost on Lockbourne Road that specializes in fast delivery and customizable pies for the south-side suburbs.[3]
When you need pizza late or on a tight schedule, this location is a workhorse, with online and app ordering dialed in for quick turnaround.[3] Drivers know the Lockbourne, Obetz, and Groveport side streets well, so delivery is typically quick and predictable.[3] The menu leans toward build-your-own and specialty pies, plus wings, breads, and desserts for a one-stop delivery night.[3]
04
Best for families and teams
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Downtown Groveport • Family Pizza And Subs Restaurant • Best For Families And Teams
A Groveport staple for thick-cut pepperoni, sturdy crust, and big combo pies that can easily feed a hungry crew.
Flyers leans into a classic central-Ohio style, with a crust sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings and a light char around the edges. The dining room is casual and family-friendly, with booths and TVs that make it an easy choice after youth games or practices. Their subs, wings, and salads round things out if some in your group want more than pizza.
05
Best for big groups and game nights
Donatos Pizza
Groveport Main Street • Local Chain Carryout And Dine-In Spot • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
Local chain favorite in Groveport turning out crisp, edge-to-edge pepperoni pies and reliable carryout orders.
This Donatos location is especially handy if you're staying near Groveport or driving back toward Lockbourne from errands or events. The trademark is the ultra-crispy, party-cut crust layered with a generous blanket of toppings, especially the signature pepperoni. Online ordering and efficient carryout make it an easy choice when you want something familiar that can feed a crowd without a long wait.