01
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Beloved by locals for generous toppings, crispy crust, and a relaxed small-town dining room.
Right in downtown Logan, Pizza Crossing is the place most locals name first when you ask where to grab a pie. The pizzas come loaded, with a slightly crunchy edge and plenty of cheese, and the menu rounds out with wings, subs, and salads. It’s a comfortable spot to linger over a pitcher and a large pie after a day exploring Hocking Hills.
02
Classic local chain
Cristy's Pizza
West Side Logan • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Delivery
A reliable Logan standby known for fast service, crowd-pleasing pies, and easy pickup or delivery.
Cristy’s sits on the west side of town and is a go-to when you want hot pizza without a sit-down meal. The crust is classic Ohio-style, with well-balanced sauce and toppings that hold up nicely to a car ride out to a cabin. It’s especially handy for larger groups, thanks to consistent quality and efficient service on busy weekends.
03
Most family-friendly
Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza
Near Old Man's Cave • Theme Pizza And Ice Cream Spot • Fun Stop With Kids
Playful pirate-themed shop serving hearty pizzas, subs, and hand-dipped ice cream close to the caves.
Just outside Logan on the way into Hocking Hills, Captain Ron’s leans into the pirate theme, making it an easy win with kids. The pizza is sturdy and satisfying, great for refueling between hikes, and the menu of subs and wings keeps everyone at the table happy. Finish with ice cream on the porch and you’ve got a full outing built around a single stop.
04
Best post-hike stop
Papa Dino's Pizzeria
South Bloomingville / Hocking Hills • Small-Town Stone-Baked Parlor • Best After The Trails
Cozy pizzeria near the heart of Hocking Hills serving stone-baked pies and hearty sides.
A short drive from Logan, Papa Dino’s feels like the classic small-town parlor you hope to find after a long day on the trails. Pizzas come out with a nicely browned, stone-baked crust and just enough char around the edges to keep each slice interesting. With subs, wings, and cold drinks, it’s a convenient gathering spot for cabin groups heading back from the parks.
05
Laid-back classic
Little Italy Pizza
East Side Logan • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Laid-Back Hangout
Unpretentious local joint turning out classic pies and slices in a relaxed, no-rush setting.
Little Italy leans old-school, focusing on familiar toppings, straightforward recipes, and friendly service over flash. It’s the kind of place where regulars know their order and staff by name, and visitors are quickly treated the same way. Grab a classic pepperoni or a simple sausage-and-onion pie and enjoy a low-key, local-feeling meal on the quieter side of town.