01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage - Circleville
Us-23 Corridor Near Logan Elm Village • Lively Family Pizza Restaurant • Local Favorite For Sit-Down And Carryout
A roomy spot just up the highway with big pizzas, friendly service, and easy parking.
For many Logan Elm Village locals, Pizza Cottage is the default choice when everyone wants pizza and nobody wants to drive far. The menu leans classic—think loaded specialty pies, thick-cut pepperoni, and cheesy breadsticks—but portions are generous and consistent. It’s especially handy on busy nights when you want a casual dine-in option right off US-23.
02
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza
Morris Road Shopping Area On The North Side • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Customizable Toppings
Crispy-edge thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings make this a reliable, build-your-own favorite.
Donatos in Circleville is a strong pick when you want a thinner, crisper crust without skimping on toppings. Their edge-to-edge style works well for sharing, since every slice gets a bit of everything. It’s an easy stop to grab takeout on your way back through town or to feed a crowd on short notice.
03
Best pizza-and-a-beer spot
Gants Pizza & Pub
Historic Downtown Circleville • Laid-Back Pub With Pizza • Best For A Casual Night Out
A cozy downtown pub where the pies are hearty and the atmosphere is relaxed and local.
Gants Pizza & Pub brings a neighborhood-bar feel to downtown Circleville, with pizza that holds its own against the tap list. The crust is sturdier and more old-school, great for loaded toppings and sharing with a table. It’s a comfortable choice when you want more of an evening out than a quick pickup run from Logan Elm Village.
04
Fastest delivery option
Domino's Pizza
East Main Street Near In-Town Neighborhoods • Delivery-Focused Chain Shop • Go-To For Quick Delivery
A dependable choice for late homework nights and game-day orders when speed matters most.
Domino’s is often the first name locals dial when they want pizza at the door rather than a drive up US-23. Online ordering, frequent coupons, and customizable crusts and sauces make it easy to keep everyone at home happy. It’s not the most atmospheric option, but for fast, predictable pizza and sides, it gets the job done.
05
Classic dine-in chain
Pizza Hut
North Court Street Commercial Strip • Classic Dine-In Pizza Chain • Nostalgic Sit-Down Option
Familiar pan pizzas, breadsticks, and booths make this an easy family meet-up spot.
Circleville’s Pizza Hut leans into the classic pan-pizza experience many people grew up with: thick, buttery crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings. It’s a convenient option for families who like the routine of sit-down service and refillable drinks without driving far from Logan Elm Village. When you want something familiar and low-fuss, this is the place.