01
Best overall pick
Cappy's Pizza
Lafayette Street Corridor • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite For All-Occasion Pizza
Cappy’s is the go-to London standby when you just want a solid, crowd-pleasing pizza everyone will agree on.[3][4]
Locals lean on Cappy’s for everything from Friday-night takeout to feeding a house full of guests.[3][4] The menu sticks to the classics—pepperoni-heavy pies, meaty specials, and simple sides—but execution is consistent and portions are generous. It’s the kind of place where calling in a large with a couple of toppings has become a London routine.
02
For loaded specialty pies
Phat Daddy's Pizza
Downtown Side Streets • Hearty Pan And Specialty Pie Spot • Best For Creative Toppings And Big Appetites
Phat Daddy’s leans into thick, filling pizzas piled high with toppings and plenty of cheese.[4][5]
This is the place London residents call when they want something a little over the top—think loaded specialty combinations and generously topped pan-style pizzas that can anchor a whole evening.[4][5] Daily and lunch specials help keep it affordable, which makes it popular with families and workers grabbing a substantial meal. If you like your slices hefty and sauce-forward, start here.
03
Family classic since 1969
Ronetti's Pizza
East Side Neighborhood • Old-School Family Pizzeria • Best For Families And Teams
Ronetti’s is a long-running London institution with a homey feel and pizza that tastes like it’s been dialed in over decades.[6]
Family-owned since 1969, Ronetti’s has strong roots in the local community and feels built for post-game team dinners and casual family nights.[6] The pizza leans classic Midwestern—crisp-edged, plenty of toppings, and easy to share—and the broader menu and banquet space make it useful when you’re feeding a big group. If you’re looking for a sit-down option with local history baked in, Ronetti’s is hard to beat.
04
Reliable thin-crust option
Donatos Pizza
High Street Strip • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Consistent Thin-Crust Delivery
London’s Donatos serves the chain’s signature edge-to-edge topping thin crust, handy when you want predictable, quick delivery.[4]
Donatos brings its familiar Columbus-born thin-crust style to London, with pizzas cut into neat squares and covered from edge to edge with toppings.[4] It’s especially convenient when you’re ordering for a group that wants something consistent and easy to divvy up, and the broader menu of subs and salads helps round out a delivery order. When you need late-week convenience more than experimentation, Donatos is a safe bet.
05
Fast and affordable
Little Caesars
Lafayette Street Shopping Strip • Budget-Friendly Carryout Counter • Best For Quick Last-Minute Takeout
Little Caesars on Lafayette keeps London stocked with hot-and-ready pizzas for those nights when speed and price matter most.[1]
Located on Lafayette Street, this branch is built around grab-and-go convenience, with familiar Hot-N-Ready pies that are easy on the wallet.[1] It’s a favorite for busy families shuttling between practices or anyone who needs to walk in, grab a couple of boxes, and be back in the car in a few minutes. While it’s not trying to be gourmet, the reliability and value earn it a spot in many London weekly routines.