01
Best old-school pick
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren • Classic Italian-American Tavern • Best For Lingering Dinners
A Warren institution turning out Old World pies in a cozy, wood-paneled dining room.
Sunrise Inn is where a lot of Trumbull County locals learned to love pizza, with sturdy crusts, generous cheese, and a long list of toppings. The Old World and specialty pies pair well with their wings and full bar, making it an easy choice when you want dinner to feel like an outing, not just takeout.
02
Quintessential Youngstown-style
Wedgewood Pizza Austintown
Austintown Mahoning Avenue Strip • Thick-Crust Youngstown-Style Shop • Local Legend
Beloved for hefty, edge-to-edge cheese and a chewy crust that defines Youngstown-style pizza.
If you ask around Lordstown where to try true Youngstown-style pizza, Wedgewood in Austintown comes up fast. Expect a slightly thicker crust, a tangy sauce, and toppings all the way to the edge, best ordered in sheet form for a crowd. It is a carryout-first spot, so plan to grab your box and head home or back to the hotel.
03
Best for game-day carryout
Cocca's Pizza Niles
Near Eastwood Mall In Niles • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Game-Day Go-To
Reliable, saucy pies and wings a short hop from Lordstown and the Eastwood Mall traffic.
Cocca's in Niles is a handy stop when you are already running errands or catching a movie near the mall. The crust runs on the softer side, with plenty of sauce and cheese, and they do well with crowd-pleasers like pepperoni, hot peppers, and loaded meat combinations. Add an order of wings or JoJo-style potatoes and you are set for watching the game at home.
04
Most flexible menu
Ianazone's Pizza Austintown
Residential Austintown Side Streets • Neighborhood Delivery Staple • Best For Late-Night Cravings
A long-running local chain known for customizable pizzas, subs, and reliable delivery hours.
Ianazone's in Austintown is a solid option when you need pizza to come to you rather than the other way around. The crust is straightforward and sturdy enough to hold extra toppings, and the menu branches out into subs, salads, and fried appetizers. It is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for Friday nights and last-minute gatherings.
05
Best small-town surprise
Gionino's Pizzeria Newton Falls
Newton Falls Town Center • Small-Town Franchise Pizzeria • Family Dinner Choice
Crisp-edged pies and famous fried chicken make this an easy compromise for families.
The Newton Falls branch of Gionino's is close enough to Lordstown to make a quick weeknight run, especially if not everyone in the group wants just pizza. Their pizzas lean toward a classic Ohio style with a slightly crispy crust and balanced sauce, and the JoJo potatoes and chicken are local favorites. It is a straightforward, friendly spot that works as well for takeout as it does for a casual dine-in meal.