01
Best overall pick
Plus 1 Pizza
Just East Of Downtown Cambridge • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Loaded Pies
A Cambridge standby known for generously topped pizzas and dependable takeout within easy reach of Lore City.
If you want the quintessential Guernsey County pizza experience, Plus 1 is a strong first stop. Pies come out hearty and well-sauced, with plenty of topping combinations and a crust that holds up on the drive back to Lore City. It’s especially handy when you want reliable takeout or delivery without overthinking the order.
02
Small-town classic
Bob's Pizza & Sub Stop
Cambridge–Lore City Corridor • Homey Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For A Low-Key Local Feel
A no-frills spot where locals grab thick, satisfying pies and straightforward subs on their way in and out of town.
Bob’s feels like the kind of place where the staff recognizes regulars and the menu stays focused on what they do well. Expect classic, comfort-style pizza with plenty of cheese, along with subs that make an easy add-on for a mixed group. It’s a solid choice when you want something filling and unfussy after a day on nearby backroads or the lake.
03
Neighborhood favorite
My Pizza Place
Village Center In Byesville • Casual Neighborhood Spot • Best For Families And Teams
A friendly Byesville shop turning out crowd-pleasing pies that work just as well for family dinner as for post-game celebrations.
My Pizza Place leans into the small-town, everyone-knows-everyone vibe, with pizza that’s easy to share and easy to like. Crusts tend to be on the classic, thicker side, with plenty of cheese and toppings aimed at kids and picky eaters as much as pizza obsessives. It’s a smart pick when you’re feeding a group and want a relaxed, no-pressure setting.
04
Hearty slice stop
Wally's Pizza
North Side Of Cambridge • Old-School Pizza Joint • Best For Big, Filling Slices
A longtime Cambridge favorite known for substantial, toppings-heavy pizzas that can easily turn one slice into a full meal.
Wally’s is the kind of place you hit when you’re really hungry and want pizza that feels substantial. The crust runs on the thicker, doughier side, built to support a serious layer of cheese and toppings. Call ahead for carryout on busy nights, then enjoy the short drive back toward Lore City with hot, heavy boxes in the back seat.
05
Most convenient delivery
Domino's Pizza
Commercial Strip Near Cambridge Retail • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Custom Orders
A familiar chain option that shines when you want fast delivery, online ordering, and lots of crust and topping combinations.
While it’s not unique to Guernsey County, the Cambridge Domino’s is a workhorse when convenience matters more than discovery. Online deals, late hours, and detailed order tracking make it a reliable go-to if you’re staying near Lore City and don’t feel like driving into town. It’s particularly useful for larger groups who want to customize several pies down to the last topping.