Lowellville sits in the heart of the Mahoning Valley, where pizza is practically its own food group. Within a short drive you’ll find old-school neighborhood shops, award-winning specialty pies, and family taverns that do pizza right. Use this list as a starting point when you’re craving a great slice close to the village.
A carryout staple for thick, sauce-forward Brier Hill pies loaded with peppers and Romano.
If you want the Mahoning Valley style that locals talk about, this Struthers shop is a must. The crust is sturdy, the sauce is the star, and the toppings lean generous rather than fussy. Call ahead, grab your boxes, and you’ll be back in Lowellville with serious hometown pizza in under 15 minutes.
A cozy bistro that treats pizza like a chef’s canvas, with toppings and combinations you won’t see everywhere.
St A's feels more like a neighborhood bistro than a corner pizza joint, but the pies are a quiet obsession for many locals. Expect thoughtfully balanced toppings, crisp yet tender crusts, and a few signature creations that lean gourmet without getting pretentious. It’s a smart pick when you want pizza that still feels like a night out.
A long-running local Italian spot where classic red-sauce pies share the table with pasta and parm dinners.
Belleria in Poland is the kind of place where kids get their own slices, grandparents order pasta, and everyone leaves full. The pizza leans traditional Mahoning Valley: chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and a familiar, slightly sweet sauce. It’s an easy go-to when your group wants a sit-down meal that still revolves around pizza.
Square-cut pizzas, cold drinks, and plenty of TVs make this a natural choice for watching the game over a pie.
Inner Circle is built for catching a game with a pizza in the center of the table. The crust is on the thinner side, cut into shareable squares with just enough crunch at the edge. Pair it with wings or a big salad and you’ve got an easy meeting point for friends coming from Lowellville, Boardman, and Poland.
A go-to for fast, reliable delivery pies with plenty of topping combos and crowd-pleasing trays.
When you want pizza to come to you, Cocca's is one of the most dependable names in the Valley. The menu is built for groups, from classic round pies to sheet pizzas that can feed a crowd without breaking the bank. It’s a practical choice for Friday nights in Lowellville, team parties, or any time you need a lot of pizza in a hurry.