01
Best overall pick
Giovanni's Pizza
Along Us-23 In Lucasville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Standby For All-Ages Dinners
The Lucasville outpost of Giovanni's is the go-to spot in town when you want a familiar, hearty pie without leaving the neighborhood.[1][2]
This Giovanni's sits right off the highway and feels like the kind of place where the staff recognizes regulars and the pizza comes out hot and generously topped.[1][2] The menu leans into crowd-pleasers—think classic pepperoni, loaded specialty pies, subs, and wings—so it works just as well for a quick takeout order as it does for a relaxed dine-in meal.[1][2] It is a reliable first stop if you are staying in or around Lucasville and want straightforward, satisfying pizza without a drive.[1][2]
02
Best for big groups
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Gallia Street In Portsmouth • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Best For Families And Team Dinners
LaRosa's in Portsmouth brings the Cincinnati-style chain’s big dining room and shareable pizzas to a spot that is an easy drive south from Lucasville.[1]
Set along Gallia Street, this LaRosa’s is a comfortable choice when you are feeding a crowd—kids, grandparents, and everyone in between.[1] The menu is broad, with customizable pies, thick and thin crusts, pastas, and appetizers, so even non–pizza people are covered.[1] It is a solid pick after ballgames, tournaments, or shopping runs in Portsmouth when you want plenty of seating and familiar flavors.
03
Best buffet option
Mr. Gatti's Pizza
Portsmouth, Just South Of Lucasville • Buffet-Style Pizza Spot • Best For Kids And Casual Meetups
Mr. Gatti's in Portsmouth is known for its pizza buffet, making it a low-stress option when nobody can quite agree on toppings.[4]
Locals head to Mr. Gatti’s for the all-you-can-eat setup, where you can graze on different pizza styles, breadsticks, and sides without waiting on individual orders.[4] The casual, family-oriented space makes it easy to linger while kids grab extra slices or try something new.[4] If you are coming down from Lucasville with a carful of people and mixed appetites, this place keeps everyone fed at their own pace.[4]
04
Worth-the-drive pick
Giovanni's Pizza
South Webster, Northeast Of Lucasville • Laid-Back Country Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Outing On Back Roads
The South Webster Giovanni's feels like a small-town staple, and it is a nice excuse for a short drive through the countryside from Lucasville.[1]
Tucked in South Webster off State Route 140, this Giovanni’s offers the same dependable formulas—cheesy pies, subs, and sides—in a quieter, more rural setting.[1] It is the kind of place where you can slow down a bit, spread out at a table, and split a large specialty pizza after a drive on the back roads.[1] If you like turning dinner into a short outing, this branch makes a pleasant change of scenery from the highway corridor.
05
Best delivery fallback
Domino's Pizza
Portsmouth, Serving Nearby Towns • Fast-Delivery Chain Pizza • Late-Night And Delivery Pick
For those nights when convenience matters more than ambiance, the Portsmouth Domino's is a dependable delivery and carryout option for Lucasville-area households.
Domino’s leans into speed and consistency, with online ordering, app deals, and a build-your-own approach that lets you stack toppings exactly how you like. If you are staying at a hotel, renting a cabin, or just do not feel like going back out, having this chain nearby is a real plus. It is not the most atmospheric choice, but when it is late, rainy, or game day, a familiar box from Domino’s can hit the spot.