01
Best overall pick
Fox's Pizza Den
West Milton Village Center • Family-Friendly Pizza Shop • Local Favorite
A small-town standby in West Milton known for generous, topping-heavy pies and a laid-back, family-friendly feel.[7][4]
Fox's Pizza Den in nearby West Milton has the classic small-town pizza-shop vibe, with big pies, subs, and plenty of carryout orders rolling out the door every night.[7][4] It is the kind of place where the staff remembers regulars, kids share baskets of wedges at the tables, and a loaded specialty pizza can easily feed a carful after an afternoon at the falls.
02
Classic small-town slice
Tom's Pizza
West Milton Outskirts • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For Carryout
A no-frills local shop turning out reliably crisp, cheesy pies that locals grab for weeknight dinners and ballgames.[4]
Tom's Pizza shows up again and again when locals rattle off their go-to spots near Ludlow Falls, thanks to its straightforward, crowd-pleasing pies and fair prices.[4] Expect a compact menu, quick service, and crust that stays sturdy under plenty of toppings—ideal when you just want to phone in a large, pick it up, and get back home before the game starts.
03
Dayton-style favorite
Cassano's Pizza King
Tipp City Corridor • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Dayton-Style Thin Crust
A regional staple for ultra-thin, square-cut Dayton-style pies piled edge-to-edge with toppings.[4]
Cassano's Pizza King, with a location an easy drive from Ludlow Falls, is where to go if you crave that distinctive, cracker-thin Dayton-style crust cut into tidy squares.[4] The edge-to-edge toppings, zippy sauce, and nostalgic, no-nonsense dining rooms make it a natural fit for families and longtime Miami Valley transplants who grew up on Cassano's.
04
Craft pizza and beer pick
Old Scratch Pizza
Downtown Troy • Craft Beer And Neapolitan-Style Spot • Best For Craft Pizza And Beer
A buzzy Troy destination pairing wood-fired, Neapolitan-inspired pies with a strong rotating craft beer lineup.[6]
Old Scratch Pizza’s Troy location brings a more modern, city-style pizza experience within a short hop of Ludlow Falls, with blistered, chewy-crusted pies fired in a blazing hot oven at the heart of the room.[6] Long communal tables, a serious tap list, and inventive toppings make it the spot to linger with friends over a couple of pies rather than just grabbing a quick box to go.
05
Reliable chain option
Donatos Pizza
South Troy Retail Strip • Takeout-Focused Pizza Chain • Best For Delivery
A familiar Ohio chain offering consistent, edge-to-edge pizzas with lots of delivery coverage around the Ludlow Falls area.[4]
For nights when convenience matters just as much as flavor, Donatos in Troy is a dependable option that still delivers a satisfying, edge-to-edge pizza.[4] Online ordering, broad delivery range, and a menu that runs from classic pepperoni to lighter cauliflower-crust options make it a practical standby for households scattered between Ludlow Falls, Troy, and the surrounding countryside.