01
Best overall pick
Vicinato Pizza
Mayfield Road Corridor • Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria • Go-To For Balanced, Crowd-Pleasing Pies
A reliable Lyndhurst staple with well-made, traditional pizzas and a friendly, low-key vibe.
Vicinato Pizza feels like the kind of spot every suburb hopes it has: consistent, unfussy, and focused on doing the basics right. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and doughy, with a good chew and enough structure to hold generous toppings. It’s an easy choice when you’re feeding a mixed group and want something everyone will be happy with.
02
Local institution
Compola's Tasty Pizza
Lyndhurst Neighborhood Spot • Family-Run Carryout Pizza Shop • Best For Old-School Charm
A longtime Lyndhurst favorite known for its nostalgic, no-frills pies and loyal following.
Compola's Tasty Pizza is the definition of a classic hometown joint, with recipes that taste like they haven’t changed in decades—in a good way. Expect a straightforward menu, ample cheese, and a crisp-edged crust that keeps people coming back. It’s especially good for call-ahead carryout on busy weeknights when you want that comforting, old-school pizza fix.
03
Carryout and delivery standout
Jet's Pizza
East Mayfield Road Strip • Detroit-Style And Round-Pan Chain Pizzeria • Best For Thick, Cheesy Slices
A fast, dependable option when you’re craving square, deep-dish slices loaded with cheese and crispy edges.
Jet’s in Lyndhurst is popular for its Detroit-style pizzas, with airy, thick crusts and caramelized cheese around the edges. The menu is broad—offering flavored crusts, wings, and salads—which makes it easy to satisfy a group with different tastes. It’s a strong choice when convenience matters but you still want something more indulgent than a standard chain pie.
04
Best for dine-in
California Pizza Kitchen
Legacy Village • Upscale Casual Pizza Restaurant • Best For Creative Toppings And Groups
A sit-down spot where you can pair inventive pizzas with salads, small plates, and a full bar right in Legacy Village.
California Pizza Kitchen at Legacy Village is ideal when you want pizza to feel like a night out rather than just takeout. Their menu leans into creative combinations—think barbecue chicken, spicy chipotle, and lighter, veggie-forward options—alongside familiar standbys. It’s a convenient pick for meeting friends, grabbing a bite before shopping, or mixing pizza with cocktails and appetizers.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Corbo's Pasta & Pizza House
Short Drive To Little Italy • Traditional Italian Bakery And Pizza House • Best For A Destination Pizza Outing
An old-school Little Italy spot that rewards Lyndhurst diners willing to make a short trip for a more classic, city-style pie.
Corbo’s is a Little Italy landmark and a smart move when you want your pizza run to feel like an outing. The pies are simple and flavorful, with a classic Italian sensibility and quality toppings, and you can tack on pastries or cookies from the bakery side while you’re there. It’s not the closest option to Lyndhurst, but it delivers on that special-occasion, ‘make an evening of it’ pizza experience.