01
Best overall pick
Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo
East Aurora Road Corridor • Classic Italian-American Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running regional favorite with hearty pies, generous toppings, and a comfortable small-town feel.
Antonio's is the place locals suggest when you simply want a solid, satisfying pizza without overthinking it. The crust has enough chew to stand up to the cheese and toppings, and the sauce leans savory rather than overly sweet. It works just as well for a sit-down family dinner as it does for big carryout orders on game day.
02
Best for fast, familiar pizza
Pizza Hut
East Aurora Road Strip • National Carryout And Delivery Chain • Most Convenient Option
A dependable stop for pan, hand-tossed, or stuffed-crust pies when convenience and predictability matter most.
If you are juggling errands along East Aurora Road, this Pizza Hut makes it easy to grab a hot pizza on your way home. The menu is exactly what you expect, which is part of the appeal for families and picky eaters. It is a practical choice when you need quick delivery or a straightforward carryout order that will please a crowd.
03
Best for customizable pies
Marco's Pizza
Near Route 8 • Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Great For Takeout Night
Build-your-own pizzas, bold seasoning, and plenty of crust options make Marco's a go-to for personalized orders.
Marco's is popular with households that like to split a few different specialty pies and still throw in a custom build for good measure. The crust tends to be a touch crisp on the outside with a soft interior, and the toppings run from classic pepperoni to more loaded combinations. It is especially handy for weeknight dinners when you want something a little more dressed up than basic chain pizza but still need delivery speed.
04
Old-school nearby classic
Farinacci Pizza
Northfield, Just North Of Town • Family-Style Neighborhood Pizzeria • Worth The Short Drive
A long-standing Northfield favorite serving thin, crackly pizzas with a homemade, family-recipe feel.
Farinacci is the kind of spot people in the northern suburbs grow up with and keep coming back to, even after they move away. The pizzas lean thinner with nicely browned edges and a sauce that tastes like it has been simmering all afternoon. It is a cozy, no-frills destination for a casual night out or a big box of slices to bring back to Macedonia.
05
Best for creative toppings
Valley Pizza Co.
Sagamore Hills Area • Casual Takeout-Focused Shop • Carryout Go-To
A small operation known for flavorful pies, generous cheese, and a few inventive topping combos that feel more local than corporate.
Valley Pizza Co. draws in regulars from Macedonia and Sagamore Hills who appreciate a well-made pie with a personal touch. The crust is sturdy enough for heavier toppings, and the kitchen is not shy about seasoning, so the pizza arrives aromatic and ready to eat. It is an easy choice when you are in the mood for something a bit different from the big chains but still want quick carryout or delivery.