01
Best overall pick
Marietta Pizza Company
Downtown Marietta • Lively Downtown Pizzeria And Bar • Local Favorite For Craft Pies
Inventive specialty pies, a laid-back bar vibe, and walkable riverfront location make this worth the easy drive from Macksburg.
Tucked into downtown Marietta, Marietta Pizza Company is the spot locals mention first when you ask about good pizza nearby. Expect chewy, flavorful crusts, generous toppings, and a menu that runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations. It is a great choice when you want a night out with friends after a day on the Muskingum or Ohio River rather than just a quick carryout box.
02
Classic valley slice
The Original Pizza Place
Marietta Pike Street Corridor • Classic Mid-Ohio Valley Pizza Shop • Best For Square-Cut Nostalgia
A long-running Mid-Ohio Valley name turning out thin, square-cut pies with a loyal following across generations.[2]
The Original Pizza Place serves the kind of crisp, square-cut pizza many folks in the Mid-Ohio Valley grew up on.[2] The crust is thin but sturdy, with toppings spread right to the edge and a tangy sauce that keeps regulars coming back. It is ideal when you want something fast and familiar on your way back up I-77 toward Macksburg.
03
Reliable delivery stand-by
Domino's Pizza
Caldwell – Just Off I-77 • National Delivery Chain • Fastest Delivery Option
For late nights or game-day cravings in and around Macksburg, Caldwell’s Domino’s is often the quickest way to get hot pizza to your door.
Because Macksburg is spread out and rural, having a dependable delivery option matters, and the Domino's in Caldwell generally covers that gap. The menu is exactly what you expect—hand-tossed, pan, or thin-crust pies with plenty of sauces and sides—so ordering for a crowd is painless. It is the practical choice when you are more focused on speed and consistency than hunting for the most artisanal slice in the region.
04
Family-night classic
Pizza Hut
Caldwell Town Center • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Kids And Big Groups
Caldwell’s sit-down Pizza Hut offers a familiar mix of pan pizzas, pastas, and a cozy booth setting that works well for families from Macksburg and nearby.
When you want an easy, kid-friendly destination after a ballgame or school event, the Caldwell Pizza Hut is an obvious choice. The thick pan crust, breadsticks, and simple salad options make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy without overthinking the order. Being right in town also means you can pair dinner with errands before heading back up the highway.
05
Best for date night
The Galley
Marietta Historic District • Upscale Tavern With Artisan-Style Pizzas • Pizza With Craft Beer And Live Music
An historic brick-walled tavern that pairs creative, tavern-style pizzas with craft beer and occasional live music in downtown Marietta.
If you are looking to make pizza feel like a proper night out, The Galley in Marietta is a strong bet. The menu leans tavern-style, with crisp, shareable pies topped with things like roasted vegetables, specialty meats, and rich cheeses, backed up by a thoughtful beer list. It is a comfortable spot for a date or a small group when you want more atmosphere than a standard carryout place can offer.