01
Best overall pick
A Tavola Bar + Trattoria
Downtown Madeira On Miami Avenue • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Destination For Pizza Lovers
A Tavola brings crisp, blistered wood-fired pies and a solid bar program right to Madeira’s main street.
If you want a pizza night that feels a little special without leaving town, A Tavola is the move. The menu leans into Neapolitan-style pies with chewy crusts, creative toppings, and just enough char from the oven to keep purists happy. Sit at the bar or on the patio with a drink and a couple of shared pies, and it quickly becomes clear why it’s a go-to for both date nights and small groups.
02
Best for families
Dewey’s Pizza – Kenwood
Near Kenwood Towne Centre • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Favorite
Dewey’s pairs inventive specialty pies with an easygoing dining room that works well for kids and groups.
Just a short drive from Madeira, the Kenwood location of Dewey’s stays busy for good reason: the crust is reliably excellent and the topping combinations are dialed in. Expect a buzz of conversation, open kitchen views, and quick service that makes weeknight dinners painless. It’s the kind of place where you can try a seasonal specialty pizza, order half-and-half pies, and still keep everyone at the table happy.
03
Classic Cincinnati pick
LaRosa’s Pizzeria – Kenwood
Montgomery Road Near Kenwood • Casual Local-Chain Pizzeria • Go-To For Familiar Flavors
LaRosa’s serves the sweet-sauced, thin-crust pies many Cincinnatians grew up on, with easy dine-in and carryout from Kenwood.
If you’re curious about what “Cincinnati-style” pizza means to locals, LaRosa’s is the most recognizable starting point. The Kenwood shop offers the full lineup of classic pies, hoagies, and wings, and it’s an easy stop on the way home from errands or the mall. It’s less about chasing the latest trend and more about that specific, nostalgic flavor people around here crave.
04
Best for craft toppings
Taglio – Montgomery
Montgomery Business District North Of Madeira • Modern Craft Pizzeria • Creative Slice And Pie Spot
Taglio leans into bold toppings and well-executed crusts, making it a strong option when you want something beyond the usual pepperoni.
Heading north from Madeira into Montgomery, Taglio feels like a modern neighborhood pizzeria with a chef’s touch. You’ll find thoughtful topping combos, quality ingredients, and a crust that strikes a nice balance between crisp and chewy. It’s especially good for sharing a couple of different pies with friends and discovering a new favorite instead of defaulting to your standard order.
05
Best late-night slice run
Ramundo’s Pizzeria – Mt. Lookout
Mt. Lookout Square, East Of Madeira • New York-Style Slice Shop • Late-Night Neighborhood Standby
Ramundo’s dishes up big New York-style slices and whole pies in a no-frills corner spot that shines when you’re craving pizza after dark.
A quick hop over toward Mt. Lookout rewards you with Ramundo’s oversize slices, best eaten folded over a paper plate. The vibe is straightforward and unfussy, with a steady flow of regulars grabbing takeout or a quick bite between stops in the square. It’s the place you keep in your back pocket for late-night cravings or when you just want a classic, floppy slice without overthinking it.